MAC A Fantasy of Flowers Collection (February 6, 2014)

mosha010

Well-known member
where is that smilie that has the little red smilie waving a roller?? lol thats me cause i know taht if my PT is nor PURPLE VEINED IM GONNA RAISE HELL! raaaaaaarrrrrrrghhhhh
 

Naynadine

Veteran Moderator
Staff member
Ugh, all those PT pics make me sad. Makes me want to boykott it and not get it, but I can't resist. I need to add it to my MSF family. But I'm not getting a BU.
 

PinkMaraschino

Well-known member
where is that smilie that has the little red smilie waving a roller?? lol thats me cause i know taht if my PT is nor PURPLE VEINED IM GONNA RAISE HELL! raaaaaaarrrrrrrghhhhh
getyou.gif
LOL!

It wouldn't be your fault though….you didn't know MAC was gonna pull this ish!!
 

BitterSweet1016

Well-known member
I wonder why MAC does that with re-promotes of certain products. Sounds like perfect topping isn't the same. They did that with Young Punk eyeshadow too when it came back out it had white veins which the original didn't have (though that didn't change how it came out thankfully) Don't they have photos of the old products to make sure they're the same. Weird. Sorry to hear so many people are a bit disappoint in the new Perfect Topping.
 

mosha010

Well-known member
:getyou:  LOL! It wouldn't be your fault though….you didn't know MAC was gonna pull this ish!!
:getyou: the fact that its called get you hahahahahaha lob it. WE SHOULD ALL BOYCOTTTT send PT back.. all of us. united we stand! if those things are not purple veined we all send them back! seriously. MAC is quick in pulling stunts like these and the customer is always right! !!!
 

MACina

Well-known member
Hello Lovelies,
Here are swatches, Natural Light NW20
Lipsticks


L - R
Dreaming Dahlia
Snapdragon
Heavenly Hybrid
Rose Lily
Naked Bud
Fleur D'Coral

Face Products

L - R

Perfect Topping
Stereo Rose
Azalea in the Afternoon
Petal Power

Fluidlines

L - R
Phlox Garden
Sassy Moss


I will post lip swatches and reviews on my blog soon hope this helps people.


There were some strange things with the packaging that I will take photos of as well so you can see! Enjoy!
Just looking at these swatches again....PT looks like a softer/lighter version of SR
th_dunno.gif
 

elegant-one

Well-known member
I have a feeling mac is going to be getting lots of perfect topping back they should of provided swatches so its all on them because the new one and the old one not alike make me wonder about sr is it going to be different to the one I had I didn't like but the first release one I think was pretty and more softer why mac why
^^^This is why I ALWAYS buy my backups right away because re-release, the product is just not quite the same :)
 

chi1216

Well-known member
Quote:Originally Posted by deadSAVVY

Only Rose Lily came courtesy of the overnight shipping. Wish it would've used the code with my big order!



Rose Lily is a light milky pink with a lavender hint to me & subtle tiny sparkles. I have pigmented lips and horrible lighting but applied sheer this lipstick is cute. Sorry I don't think I have a similar color to compare it to (slacking on the light pink game) and I apologize for the crappy pic quality/ lighting in advanced it was taken with front facing cam pics


It's cute on you!
 

ladyd12

Well-known member
[qNe name="Ndpendent Hussy" url="/t/185975/mac-a-fantasy-of-flowers-collection-february-2014/3210#post_2560291"]Here is Phlox Garden and Sassy Moss on NW45 skin.   This green is the business!  I can already see it as a base with Chartreuse Bouquet.  Phlox Garden is a beautiful purple.:eyelove:    [/quote]Thank you for helping me make a decision, NW45 twin lol.
 

LiliV

Well-known member
Hello Lovelies,  Here are swatches, Natural Light NW20 Lipsticks L - R  Dreaming Dahlia  Snapdragon  Heavenly Hybrid Rose Lily Naked Bud  Fleur D'Coral Face Products L - R  Perfect Topping  Stereo Rose  Azalea in the Afternoon  Petal Power Fluidlines L - R  Phlox Garden  Sassy Moss  I will post lip swatches and reviews on my blog soon hope this helps people.   There were some strange things with the packaging that I will take photos of as well so you can see! Enjoy!
Thanks for these! You're pretty close to my skintone. Fleur d'Coral looks much nicer than I thought but I'm going to pass bc I have a very similar color. I really like Snapdragon! I might try to grab that when it comes on Nordstrom or something
 

Serenityy

Well-known member
Rose Lily is a light milky pink with a lavender hint to me & subtle tiny sparkles. I have pigmented lips and horrible lighting but applied sheer this lipstick is cute. Sorry I don't think I have a similar color to compare it to (slacking on the light pink game) and I apologize for the crappy pic quality/ lighting in advanced it was taken with front facing cam pics
YASSS girl this is soooo pretty on you! I love it on you!! I can not wait to get mine now!
eyelove.gif
 

Naynadine

Veteran Moderator
Staff member
It's probably the same reason why the Lightscapade repromotes had little to no blue veining. Didn't someone say that the ingredients to make it got more expensive?
 

elegant-one

Well-known member
Rose Lily is a light milky pink with a lavender hint to me & subtle tiny sparkles. I have pigmented lips and horrible lighting but applied sheer this lipstick is cute. Sorry I don't think I have a similar color to compare it to (slacking on the light pink game) and I apologize for the crappy pic quality/ lighting in advanced it was taken with front facing cam pics
OMGosh you are so adorable! Very pretty...pretty lady!
 

Odelia

Well-known member
I wonder why MAC does that with re-promotes of certain products. Sounds like perfect topping isn't the same. They did that with Young Punk eyeshadow too when it came back out it had white veins which the original didn't have (though that didn't change how it came out thankfully) Don't they have photos of the old products to make sure they're the same. Weird. Sorry to hear so many people are a bit disappoint in the new Perfect Topping.
Yeah, Mac should seriously just stop re-promoting things....More often than not they can't replicate it -_-
 

Ndpendent Hussy

Well-known member
For the ladies curious about comparable shades, I found a couple of similar shades in my stash. I didn't want to shame my self and pull out all my purples!

L-R Heavenly Hybrid (lustre), Feel My Pulse (creamsheen), Midnight Mambo (mineralize rich)

With Flash


Hope this helps!
 
Top