MAC A Fantasy of Flowers Collection (February 6, 2014)

lipstickaddict

Well-known member
If that's what PT looks like with no purple. i'm skipping. Where is all the purple veinyness!
Right! I am very glad now that I didn't order online. It will be interesting to see if there are ones with more purple or pink--likely the girls will let me look through a bunch on Thursday. Here's hoping!
 

vaisforluvrs

Well-known member
@liba If those are one's that you are ALSO lusting after, which ones do you want the most? Just looked up the collection. Is it the other unicorn ones with the tassel?
 

mosha010

Well-known member
dysebeva.jpg
Phlox on lids and HH on lips. PT to highlight. Just very quick and not the best but I have 15min to hurry and go to my jeepclub meet.
 

Starlight77

Well-known member
This was my question too.
the lady just said she would send me a new one. i didn't have to fight for it or anything. she was so nice and so pleasant too.


Originally Posted by brittbby


I hope so too
ssad.gif
I imagined it going so wonderfully with my new SF blush from NARS. I may have to try to get to the I store launch if the next one is bad too...
So true!!! I hope it looks flattering on. All the pale beauties may like this better if they didn't like previous years but I was hoping for an exact BU
I didn't get the SR because it was too dark and orangey looking on my skin tone the first release, I see in your swatches it's lighter but what color does it lean towards. i'm reading off a cell and i can't really see it that close. thanks :)
 

lipstickaddict

Well-known member
Good lord, ladies.

I so much want to get in on the conversation here, but this thread has blown up beyond all magnitudes of proportion. I do not have what it takes to catch up on 600 posts since yesterday, lol.
girlhaha.gif
th_crazy.gif


Anyhow, thanks to everyone posting swatches!

Sassy Moss and Phlox Garden are still LOVE LOVE LOVE and I cannot wait to have them in my hands. Sassy Moss is even more amazing than I'd hoped - good lord that is going to be worn non-stop in a mega cats eye by MOI all spring and summer long.

The lippies are driving me crazy, because I know I've got near dupes of them all. I am going in tomorrow to see the whole collection in person and am bringing a big makeup bag filled with my potential dupes to double check. Actually, the one that seems the least like everything else I own is Dreaming Dahlia - it's looking like a deeper Sushi Kiss, or a more pastel Toxic Tale, which is again PURE LOVE.

I can't be too crazy with this collection because I just got an email about a pre-sale next week on the most beautiful shoes my shoe lovin' heart has ever seen. Check out these unbelievable princesses:

Frikken glorious - I don't even care what they're going to cost. If I ever get married, I'm wearing these babies, lol.

Quote: Originally Posted by AkeshialuvsMAC

Love ur swatches they look so nice! Sassy moss doesnt look green tho or is it my phone?

Liba! Thank goodness you are here! I have been patiently waiting to hear your thoughts on the products, especially as I haven't ordered a thing and am definitely going to check these babies out in person to decide if I want anything. Can't wait to read your review!
 

lipstickaddict

Well-known member
I hope everyone who is not happy with their MSFs returns them.
Same here. But I wonder if the MSF's are all like this, or if there are some duds. It's possible, but I have seen pictures of this year's version of PT online, and while Elegant one's still knocks them out of the park, they have a lot more veining that what I am seeing here. Hmmm....
 

Whitneyallison

Well-known member
I don't want to go through the hassle but I think I'm going to have to. I want my perfect topping to be "pink" like the description. Do you have to pay for return shipping?
19847524_image.jpeg
(just arrived at my door a few hours ago)
 

lipstickaddict

Well-known member
Well...now I don't know if I should feel bamboozled...or happy about my Perfect Topping...at first I wasn't bothered by my swirls, but now this thread is making me rethink that.
Don't be bamboozled! If you like the new one, that's great! Personally I think it is very pretty, and if you didn't have certain expectations of what it would look like, you may be perfectly satisfied! It sucks that Mac isn't consistent, but don't let all of the negative feedback spoil it for you. Just like some of the girls love the new stereo rose, some may like the softer looking PT!
 
Top