I've used these:
BE warmth-works well for me-some don't like it b/c it can be muddy(don't know my MAC foundation but I'm fairly light and probably warm.
Bonne Belle gel bronzer-I've used this-I can't tell much difference in my face but honestly I haven't experimented much with it
MK bronzing beads-have a little trouble with getting the right amount, but it's okay
Arbonne-this is what I'm using right now, and am having great luck with it. It has some shimmer(unlike the others) and looks scary to me in the compact, but looks natural on me(w/ a kabuki brush)