i've tried all three mascaras, but i only own diorshow and blinc. blinc is the one i wear most of the time because it doesnt smudge AT ALL. i've never had a problem removing it, all you have to do is wet your lashes with warm water, rub, and it alll comes off. it give a bit of volume and length, good for everyday. i can't live without it! diorshow i love because it curls my little lashes and gives AWESOME volume. it's also easy to wash off which is good because i hate scrubbing around my eyes. the only thing is that this smudges on me. i never really got into bad gal, i tried it a couple of times, but it just really clumped my lashes..but i know it works great for one of my friends. so there's my two cents.