You guys are going to hate me, but I already got both collections. I was much more excited about Chill than Dame Edna initially, but now that I have both, I really feel that Dame Edna will be the one I use more. The Chill colors really wash you out, especially the lip glosses which have a blue undertone and make you look literally frozen and slightly dead :>). The pen liner is nice but is very similiar in my opinion to Stila's liquid eye liner pen which can be found at Ulta for $20. Overall, I would recommend putting your money into Dame Edna. It is a fun collection with endless possibities for different looks. Chill, on the other hand, is really going to give you slightly different versions of the same look (make sense?) and is probably not a look that you will want to use in the Spring and Summer whereas Dame Edna can be used all year round. Hope that helps! Let me know if you have any questions.