Dupe for Mulch e/s?!?

[Perple1]

Hey ladies ~ I am looking for a dupe for Mulch - drugstore is fine. In fact, does the L'oreal HiP line have a dupe? I have checked what others consider to be a dupe in the Milani line and it looks to be more of a Twinks-type color.

-- nothing against Twinks, already have it...
Please help! TIA

 

[Fairybelle]

It's not a 'drugstore' line, but you could try Flirt! Cosmetics which is sold at Kohls. The darkest brown they have is Dreamy Eyes Eyeshadow in Coconutty. All of the powder products I have purchased from them have a pretty nice consistency, very smooth.
Or you could try Covergirl single eyeshadow in Swiss Chocolate, or the darkest shadow in Shimmering Sands (3-shadow kit).
I know Mulch is a shimmery dark brown...very pigmented. I'll keep looking for you!

 

[Perple1]

Fairybelle, thanx - that's so sweet. I really appreciate the help!