Dupe for Sablecoated e/s?*pics*

[aleksis210]

So I went into MAC the other day and told the lady I want a neutral or cool matte brown closest to the discontinued color Sablecoated...When I brought the color home (charcoal brown) I realized they don't look anything alike..Can you ladies recommend a good dupe?

Here's some pics!
(All pics are true to color!)
*Charcoal brown, the color I was recommended

*SableCoated(in the middle)

*Side by Side comparison

 

[NicksWifey]

Seeing that pic of Sablecoated in that palette reminds me a lot of Folie e/s, although Folie may have some more red tones to it.

 

[aleksis210]

Quote:

Originally Posted by NicksWifey Seeing that pic of Sablecoated in that palette reminds me a lot of Folie e/s, although Folie may have some more red tones to it.

Thanks Brit!...for some reason any browns that are warm look really,really bad on me...

 

[aleksis210]

Hmmm so I'm thinking 'Handwritten' or 'Espresso'...are these close? p.s. even though I like cool browns...I have no idea if Sablecoated is actually cool/neutral or not, it's simply a guess...

 

[aleksis210]

 

[aleksis210]

**fixed the pictures!

 

[TISH1124]

Looks like Mac Brun to me...which is described as a Muted Blackish brown color

 

[aleksis210]

^Thanks babe!

 

[ladyJ]

It kind of looks like espresso to me but I could be wrong. (sorry)

 

[tiramisu]

Well, I can't see the pics, but I personally love such cool matte browns as:
Mystery (neutral matte dk brown with hint of plum =this looks great on my skin tone and I use it all the time!!)
and Espresso. Brun is also good matte neutral!

You're right BTW-- charcoal brown conjures up images of a cool brown, but that looks totally warm in your pic!!

 

[jbid]

i agree with folie, in my screen it looks the same.

 

[Kiss and Makeup]

What about Corduroy, or would that one be too warm?