I must have a very watery eye because I can never get eyeliner to actually apply to the water line. I have tried pencil liners (various) and all the gel liners (BB, Stila, MAC). Would MAC power points work?
I find that MAC eye kohls work much better, actually. I have a hard time trying to get powerpoints to show on the waterline. Strangely enough I find that one that works best on my waterline is the Maybelline smudge-proof kohl.
The only MAC liner that I have had success with on my waterline is Smolder Eye Kohl -- I have tried Navy Stain PowerPoint and Teddy Eye Kohl and neither of them work for me... but Smolder is fantastic!!!
The powerpoint is supposed to be waterproof (which it why i bought it, to use in my waterline) but i find that it's hard to even get it ON the waterline. if you use it on the eyelid, etc it does stay on well though.
I use black eyeshadow in my waterline, (MAC's Beauty Marked) and it stays on even in all the heat and when I go to clubs! You can also use Kohl liner ontop of that.
I find this is what works best
I use prestige waterproof, stayed on so well not only in the waterline (yes, the waterline!) but on the skin that I needed to look for a new makeup remover strong enough to remove it!!!!!!!!!! (still got dark stains from the weekend!!!!!...nothing concealer can't fix for now)
I use a waterproof estee lauder liquid liner..it seems to work the best...for some reason not even the fluidlines manage to stay on my eye :-(
I was told my a Stila artist once to use a smudgepot then an e/s of teh same color over it packed on to make it stay...it actually does stay on longer this way..and u can try it with a fluidline