Hmm,.. I dont think that I have ever had much trouble with my Stillife? That is one of my staples. If you apply it too thickly I did notice however that it will crack and look kinda bumpy? But they all do that if they are too thick. I usually get that problem when I apply it with something else besides my 242 or my fingers, which is what I normally use.
Try applying a shimmery eyeshadow wet to your eyelid without a base,.. that should kinda give you an idea if it is your primer or you lid.