Grand Entrance in Holiday Palette different than Starflash?

[chickatthegym]

I was just going through my collection and realized that I have the Grand Entrance shadow from the Starflash collection AND the Grand Entrance in the Intriguing Scarlet palette... they are two totally different colors! What is the deal? Did anyone else notice this?

 

[MissResha]

Wtf????

 

[Mabelle]

yea, i noticed this when the eye palettes came out.
i'm suprised no one has mentioned it before actually.

you would think that after all the LE and perm colours mac had come out iwth, there would be repeat names. But these shadows were within like 2 months of each other!

 

[erine1881]

they are two completely different colors and finishes, they just have the same name.

and seeing as how the grand entrance in the holiday palette is a forest green, and the starflash one is cream colored, i'd say they're different, wouldn't you?

 

[Simply Elegant]

MAC likes to reuse names sometimes. I'm pretty sure it was brought up in another thread.

 

[onepinkdiamond]

This brings an interesting question about the Lucky Tom palette from the HK collection.... Has anyone swatched the permanent paradisco next to the one in the palette? It's definitely much pinker. Needless to say, MAC does NOT stay true to their shades. Just thought I'd throw that out there.