I really didnt like this mascara. I have ridiculously long lashes, and lengthening mascaras makes them look worse. I much prefer volume which tends to open up my eyes more, and give a lush glamorous look. The YSL in particular, gives a spiders leg effect on me and i find the tube dried up rather quickly too - not good. If possible, try it before you purchase. Largely depends on your preferences, and what you want your mascara to focus on for you, but i wouldnt recommend this.