Help are these real ?

[Chupla]

Are these fake or real ?



http://cgi.ebay.com/MAC-Pigment-eyeshadow-GOLDENAIRE-Ltd-Edition-RARE-/400162967764?pt=US_Makeup_Eyes&hash=item5d2b9250d4

http://cgi.ebay.com/MAC-PIGMENT-EYE-SHADOW-SMOKE-SIGNAL-RETIRED-NIB-F-S-/250710837546?pt=US_Makeup_Eyes&hash=item3a5f87c92a

 

[rockin]

I can't see properly on the Goldenaire, but I'd be highly suspicious after seeing the pics of their Landscape pigment . Also their 'Starflash' collection items - I looked at one and saw it had a code of A39. I checked and saw that the Starflash collection was from 2008, so surely that would be wrong? Personally I wouldn't risk it. I remember possibly last year there was a 'charity' seller that had heaps of fake pigment they were trying to pass off as genuine.

 

[rockin]

Just checked - it's the same 'charity' seller. Here's a previous thread about them http://www.specktra.net/forum/thread/155897/national-relief-charities-selling-pigments-are-these-real#post1857268

 

[Chupla]

Thanks so much =)