After a recommendation here I got Patina and use it now as a crease colour, with Shroom as a wash on the entire lid. I've got blue eyes, too, and I feel it's a very polished and subtle look that enhanced the blue.
But I also already tried Patina all over lid and smudged into the lower lashline for a smoky look which isn't too dark (I even wore it to the office, it looked quite nice).
So I think it depends a little on what kind of look you'd like to achieve!