How similar are Beige-ing and Butternutty shadesticks ?

[Lotte]

I just bought Beige-ing at a CCO.
I want to get the new shadesticks from the Sugarsweet collection as well but how similar are Beige-ing and Butternutty ?

Thanks !

 

[TISH1124]

Courtesy of Mayjkal

 

[3773519]

yea thats pretty close to me.