I finally found it!

[midge]

So, of course, being the loser that I am, I've never had a red lipstick. I've never felt like red looked good on me, but I'm in love with Fire Shine by L'Oreal. I'm so excited now. XD I'll try to find a picture for you lovely ladies.

And for this to have a purpose... what color red do you think looks best on you?

 

[Hilly]

Ohh I love all blue Reds! Definitely Russian Red!

 

[MACATTAK]

I'm with Hilly! Russian Red with a gloss on top is my favorite!

 

[foomph]

I really like Dubonnet and MAC Red

 

[Dani California]

I like Prescriptives Meteor gloss.

 

[ShesAFoxyLady]

I like Rimmel's Scream... as here (excuse clashing eye makeup & jumper, I was just playing around with the red at home)...