Is NYX Loose Pearl Pigment in Oro really a MAC Melon dupe?

[Mizz.Coppertone]

I read this after googling a suggestion for one. Is it true?

Thanks.

 

[Mizz.Coppertone]

Anybody?

Here is Oro for reference:


I do not own Melon so I have no clue. What do you think? Does it look close?

 

[MACATTAK]

That does not look at all like Melon to me, it looks more like a dupe for Mac's Tan.

 

[Mizz.Coppertone]

Ugh I still don't know if I should order this.

 

[Mizz.Coppertone]

bump...


anyone else? does nyx have a dupe?