hmm.. as far as MAC brand,I would try BBQ or Cork. they're both a little lighter though. What color foundation are you? you could try Cushy cremestick liner too (little bit lighter still).
Also, take a look at MAC's Hodgepodge. And it might not hurt to look at 80% Creamstick liner. I'm not exactly sure but it may have a bit less red than Chestnut.