I would reccomend you:
Patina shadow - a brown with blue reflect that will bring out your eyes
Naked Lunch shadow - a neutral that is suitable for everyday "quick swipe" type of makeup
Juiced shadow - orange eyeshadows can really bring out blue eyes, this one is more subtle and has pink shimmers
Black Tied shadow - to line/smoke out any look, this is a basic
Depending on which formula you like (go to a counter/store to try them out) the shadestick in Bei-jing or the paint in Bare Canvas are great bases that will make your shadow last all day
Richground Fluidline (you will also need a small angled brush) - beautiful on blue eyes and is a shimmer medium coco color
Duck Powerpoint Eye Pencil - an eye pencil in a creamy, easy to slide on formula, this color will also flatter blue eyes nicely; I would reccomend purchasing MAC's sharpener as well because it does the best job on these pencils ($3.00)
Blushbaby blush - this is fairly neutral, and it sounds as you may have a cool skintone (NW's) so this will work on you
Maidenchant blushcreme - this is out with the Lure collection, and if you are able to find it you may love it, its a cool toned shimmery pink that would look excellent on someone with blue eyes
Nymphette lipglass - this is one of the shades, along with Prrr, that are fairly basic yet super beautiful; this one is a nice subtle pink with gold shimmers
Viva Glam V lipglass - depending on your skin tone (depth) this may look to dark/light; but for most it is the perfect neutral, along with the matching lipstick
Depending on if you hate the sticky feel of lipglasses, I would also reccomend trying the Lip Gelee's in Cellopink or Slicked Pink; or the Lustreglass in Wonderstruck, Morning Glory, or Luminary
Plink! lipstick - this is a shimmery pink that feels like a gloss on the lips and is light
Snob lipstick - pale pinky purple that is really flattering on a cool complexion