Here is Haunting and Delphic compared to Aquadisiac and Lovely Lily.
They are identical except for the surface difference being powder vs, cream. The different reflection of light makes them look just a tiny different, but in real life, they are identical.
As you can see in the one photo where the haunting/LL is tilted, they look different because of the surface reflection of light- straight on they look just a like.
Here are some photos that I took (notice that Nightfish looks just like black/brown mascara smudged there)