I've been less interested in the older MSFs - they just don't have the great textures the newer ones have. Even the repromotes don't update the texture, normally (probably because they use the same formula). You are making Perfect Topping sound great, though.
I WISH!
It's all right, but I think it got really hyped up originally because it was so much harder to find strong coral cheek products back then. I bought it with In the Groove and used to use it a lot, but I think the texture is old fashioned and a bit heavy now, compared to newer MSFs or the EDSFs. For younger skin, it'd still be fine, but it's not super unique any longer. I'd rather wear an EDB like Flaming Chic or Blazing Haute or My Paradise, which looks very similar on me, but better texture.
You're also making Perfect Topping sound beautiful. You don't find it too powdery or frosty?
These colors are so pretty but I've been sort of losing interest in CSGs (crazy, I know!). I'm much more into the texture of the Huggable Lip Colours or the Mineralize Lip Balms nowadays - it's a softer look.