MAc cleanse off oil vs DHC oil cleanser?

[jackie100]

I want to get an oil cleanser and debating between the two.. do you have any input as to which one is better?

Just want something to take off my makeup, eye makeup, sunscreen, primer etc...

From what I read the Mac one has a thinner consistency and might be slightly better at removing eye makeup... Any other differences?

 

[xxsgtigressxx]

I love both! But I think it comes down to preference. I like MAC's because I think it rinses off easier, but my mom likes DHC better (which I think is thicker). I think MACs cleanse off oil is one of their best products and it takes all my make off really quickly and easily

 

[gildedangel]

I like the MAC one better!