I had the same problem with the one I got, which was the blue one from Tartan Tale. It was the worst beauty product I ever bought. It had the weirdest texture, so gritty and rough, my lids swole up, and it was a pain to remove it. And what was more weird, I think mine went bad after only a couple of weeks, and I only used it once or twice. When I wanted to give it another try after some weeks, it was completely dry and hard, it was impossible to apply to the skin. I always make sure that I close all my beauty products properly, and it was stored in a cool and dry place. I don't know if somehting was wrong with it from the start, but I know for sure that I won't buy any of these again.