MAC Satin Taupe vs NARS Ashes to Ashes


Well-known member
Is it just me or are these 2 shadows basically the same color??

is it worth having both of them??



Well-known member
oh I am glad you've asked this, even though you've received no responses. LOL
I just purchased ashes to ashes at Nars online.. hoping that it is like Satin Taupe --Can anyone help us??

You know what Beauty_Marked? Now that I've gotten the NARS e/s in the mail and had a chance to play with it a bit-- it is sooo very pretty on that I don't even care what Satin Taupe is like,LOL as it appears close "enough" in tone/shade.

The NARS one is that pretty.. it's a must have. It is the best cold taupe/gray brown with a hint of plummy-ness and shimmer you could ask for-just gorgeous. It looks pretty even all on it's own..