MAC Shadesticks vs. Bobbi Brown Shimmer Cream Shadow Sticks?

[Piaqua]

I've never tried the Bobbi Brown ones, can someone compare these for me please? How similar are they?

 

[user3]

I find BB's cream sticks to be smoother than MAC's. They both have the same lasting power on me. which is not long even with a base.

 

[pugmommy7]

how about creasing?

I love my shadesticks, and I never thought I would, with my greasy ol' eyelids, but I do...
I think that may change come summer...
but alas I have to pass a Mac counter to get to BB at Nordie's, so I rarely make it

...an i really want a peony shimmerbrick wah!