MAC X Philip Treacy Collection (March 26 / April 2, 2015)

[patentg33k]

What swatches are you ladies going off of? T's are uneventful. Everything looks like a Lustre to me. Then I saw one from the "bad T" word that looked good...

We were looking at these: http://blogger.makeup-box.com/2015/03/mac-philip-treacy-collection.html



Others:

 

[NaomiH]

We were looking at these:  http://blogger.makeup-box.com/2015/03/mac-philip-treacy-collection.html Others:

Those don't even look like they're from the same collection! :shock: I hope the makeup box swatches are the accurate ones

 

[YarahFlower]

Those don't even look like they're from the same collection! :shock: I hope the makeup box swatches are the accurate ones

Me too!

 

[lipstickaddict]

Me either! It doesn't look super pretty like the other pic we saw

NFP doesn't really look like that irl, so I'm hoping its her lighting.

Her lighting seems dark--not picking up the brighter tones. T's swatches of NFP are far more accurate considering the brightness factor

 

[Dolly Snow]

Those don't even look like they're from the same collection! :shock: I hope the makeup box swatches are the accurate ones

I hope so too

 

[lipstickaddict]

We were looking at these: http://blogger.makeup-box.com/2015/03/mac-philip-treacy-collection.html



Others:

I'm looking at NFP right now and Temptalia is way more accurate. Gives me hope for HC!

 

[elegant-one]

What swatches are you ladies going off of? T's are uneventful. Everything looks like a Lustre to me. Then I saw one from the "bad T" word that looked good...

I guess I saw it on T this morning not here. I thought it looked very pretty on T. That's why I ordered 2

 

[NaomiH]

I'm looking at NFP right now and Temptalia is way more accurate. Gives me hope for HC!

Eep! *goes to cancel NFP order*

 

[montREALady]

We were looking at these:  http://blogger.makeup-box.com/2015/03/mac-philip-treacy-collection.html Others:

Yeah T's do nothing for me. Just saw that new one before but I thought you guys were talking about other ones. Thanks.

 

[YarahFlower]

I'm looking at NFP right now and Temptalia is way more accurate. Gives me hope for HC!

she is known for her inaccuracies, as it pertains to coloring. I don't trust it!...we won't truly know until we get it I guess :shrugs:

 

[elegant-one]

I'm looking at NFP right now and Temptalia is way more accurate. Gives me hope for HC!

Hi friend! Yep, those are the pics I saw this morning. They are more accurate

 

[YarahFlower]

Yeah T's do nothing for me. Just saw that new one before but I thought you guys were talking about other ones. Thanks.

The red in the makeup box blog post, looks more like the red we saw in one of the promo pics...the pic you really liked

 

[Mizani]

I like it too! You'd think I'd know better by now to not eat and Specktra, but apparently I don't. :haha:

LOL @ eat and "Specktra". Who knew it could be a verb!! :lol:

 

[NaomiH]

The red in the makeup box blog post, looks more like the red we saw in one of the promo pics...the pic you really liked

:agree: I wanted it due to that behind the scenes pic we saw. The makeup box pic looks like it was taken in more natural light to me (could be my phone) so fingers crossed!

 

[lipstickaddict]

We never know until we get it anyway! All buying blindly! I like her swatches though, makes me want the other 2, lol. I'll wait until I see them in store.

This is true. My order isn't here until "Wednesday....drums fingers.....

 

[elegant-one]

I don't think makeup box ones are accurate because if you look at the 3 lipsticks photo right above the hand swatches, NFP doesn't even look close to that in the tube irl.

 

[lipstickaddict]

The red in the makeup box blog post, looks more like the red we saw in one of the promo pics...the pic you really liked

It absolutely does. I love that red in the promo pic too! Ahhh shucks.....

 

[Vineetha]

I don't think makeup box ones are accurate because if you look at the 3 lipsticks photo right above the hand swatches, NFP doesn't even look close to that in the tube irl.

I hope so!! I want HC to be closer to T's swatch for once!!

 

[lipstickaddict]

I don't think makeup box ones are accurate because if you look at the 3 lipsticks photo right above the hand swatches, NFP doesn't even look close to that in the tube irl.

Nope! It doesn't. I think we can rest easy that there is more berry in HC. Then again, it could be one of those cameleon lippies that drive us batty.

 

[NaomiH]

If I remember correctly, I think Karly's HC swatch looked more purpley too.