MAC x Proenza Schouler (April 24, 2014)

laralara

Well-known member
This shade works amazingly well on you! Love it!
iagree.gif
 

NewChick10

Well-known member
Quote:Originally Posted by chinablaq


Thank you! Mangrove is definitely my fav of the 3
smiles.gif



There is something that drives me to Mangrove. I wish there were some dupes out there so that I could at least see if I already have that color hidden in my makeup stash. How do you like it as far as being swatched on your lips? Does it present differently?
 

laralara

Well-known member
Quote:


There is something that drives me to Mangrove. I wish there were some dupes out there so that I could at least see if I already have that color hidden in my makeup stash. How do you like it as far as being swatched on your lips? Does it present differently?

I'm wondering about this with woodrose, as I'm also sure I have dupes in my collection. I love nude lippies!!
 

alexisweaver

Well-known member
Temptalia's review/ swatches for the lipsticks are up: http://www.temptalia.com/mac-x-proenza-schouler-lipsticks-reviews-photos-swatches
 

MissTania

Well-known member
Temptalia's review/ swatches for the lipsticks are up: http://www.temptalia.com/mac-x-proenza-schouler-lipsticks-reviews-photos-swatches
Mangrove does look pretty
sigh.gif


Pinkfringe reminds me of Hello Kitty Strayin'- which is a colour I wish I had backed up more (I only got one BU when I was on vaykay in San Fran, and I think they had a second one and I restrained myself as I had one in operation already).

If it is close to Strayin'- this could get very expensive as I will get at least 3
eyelove.gif
 

allthingsglam

Well-known member
t swatcheswoodrose looks so light mangrove flashbacks to ablaze @liba do u think ablaze and mangrove have similar color.t swatches the plum colored one looks redI'm so confused now and pinkfridge is just sexy looking still on my list
 

Spanky

Well-known member
I think mac got ahead of themselves trying to push all these collections out at once.
I've said this a million times...but I'll say it again. Ever MAC since AG's, YOS & ED 2013 came out there was always at least 1 thing that was unavailable online. Like the 3 EDSFs those were available on dept. store sites before MAC's site for a couple weeks. It's ridiculous. They keep throwing all these LE collections at us & they can't keep up. If they would slow up on how much they are pumping out they perhaps they wouldn't have all these delays. It's very frustrating & let's be honest when it's LE items, often there isn't much time for one to sit. & really think about what they are buying. If you wait too long & sadly sometimes that's 5 min., it's gone & that's frustrating.
 

Spanky

Well-known member
Thanks for the swatches, Erin! I will skip Mangrove, since I already own Dangerous and Nars Heat Wave (both are very similar). I don't need a third lipstick in this shade.
Great, thanks for saying this b/c I have Heat Wave in my wishlist. So if I can get Mangrove i won't need HW.
 

Spanky

Well-known member
Thanks for the swatches, Erin! I will skip Mangrove, since I already own Dangerous and Nars Heat Wave (both are very similar). I don't need a third lipstick in this shade.
I'm getting freaked out Elegant b/c I can't keep up. I'm sorry if you've said this 1000 times but how did you get your PS items already if you dint mind my asking.
They only charged me $6 shipping for Mangrove
 

ladyarwen

Well-known member
Whoa, Christine says the lipsticks are $16. I thought they were $22?

EDIT: She fixed it to $22. Kind of a shame, I wouldn't have minded snatching Mangrove for $16.
 
Top