MAC's equivalent to Stila's Puck?

[kathyp]

One of my favorite eyeshadows, Puck, from Stila, was discontinued. It was sort of a sheer mauve-y, taupe-y color with the tiniest hint of shimmer. Is there a MAC shade that's pretty close that's not too flat/matte or loaded with shine?

 

[ForgetRegret]

I've never actually seen puck in person, so I'm just going by what the swatch looks like...it looks somewhat similar to Arena. I've got Arena at home, and it's not too shimmery, it's a very pretty color. Is there a MAC store or counter near you that you can swatch it and compare to puck?

 

[kathyp]

Thanks. I'll look for Arena next time I'm at Macy's. Unfortunately, I don't have Puck anymore to compare the two, but going by the website swatch, Arena looks a bit warmer, I think.

 

[ForgetRegret]

Yeah, it did look a little warmer, but it was the only shadow that came close to the puck swatch. When you see it in person, it may actually wind up being closer to puck than it appears...you know how the MAC swatches can be sometimes...