Need color recs for my skin tone, please!

[curlyqmishee]

Hi ladies.

I was told by the MAC MA that I am warm-toned, so I started wearing warm colors, but I don't think they look so good on me. Doesn't this makeup look "all wrong" for my skintone?

http://img.makeupalley.com/8/2/4/2/532555.jpeg

Does this FOTD look better?

http://img.makeupalley.com/8/2/4/2/532557.jpeg

What colors would be most flattering to me?

Looking for straight-up advice from my beautiful Specktra sisters!

Thank you so much!

 

[ebonyannette]

I like the second one. She may have said you were warm because of your hair color? Thats not the case you look cool to me

 

[Juneplum]

moved to recs

 

[maxcat]

I like them both - but it's more what you're comfortable with. She probably meant that you're an NW instead of an NC (which is what it looks like to me) - there has been mucho debate over what the "W" and "C" really mean - but essentially NWs are peachier/pinker skintones while NCs are more golden. It's confused a lot of people.
I think you'd look nice in paler plums and lavenders, like dovefeather, quarry, vex...

 

[captain planet]

hey i think the second looks better but i agree with max.. above!