Personally, I prefer a bit of shimmer, so I'd go with Springsheen (which I have). I've really been using Fleurry lately. It's peachy-corally with a bit of shimmer. I had Peaches at one point, but like I said, I prefer shimmer. It's really going to depend on your skintone as to which peach one is going to look best. I'm NW15 for reference.