Pro longwear or Select cover-up?

[antigone21]

So I just came back from the MAC counter, I thought I had purchased the Pro longwear but turns out the make up artist made a mistake and gave me the Select cover up instead (in the same shade). I was wondering if I should give it a go, or go back and exchange it. Which concealer do you prefer better and why? I want to use it mainly on my dark spots from acne as a replacement to my Studio finish.

 

[Diva4eva122]

EXCHANGE IT NOW select sucks, it is like putting water on your face.

 

[afulton]

agreed!

EXCHANGE IT NOW select sucks, it is like putting water on your face.

 

[antigone21]

Thanks!!! I almost caved in and opened it, but I didn't yet. I'll go back tomorrow.

 

[Diva4eva122]

goood, hopefully they get it right this time

 

[antigone21]

I'm so glad I went back for the right thing, Pro longwear seems amazing so far! Great coverage and application, can't say anything about the lasting power yet but so far so good. NC42 is a better match than the NC42 in Studio finish. Pump is annoying, but I already knew it was a problem and it doesn't bother me that much, you just have to be careful.