If you want something more subtle, I would try out Blushbaby. If you want something a little brighter, try Dollymix. It looks scary in the pan, but it actually goes on pretty sheer and it has some shimmer to it.
I usually try to stick to the 'sheertone' blushes if I am going for a brighter shade, that way I don't have to worry about looking like a clown. Just make sure you test them out on your hand/inner arm first!