Same color, new name?

[Clada]

Since MAC has sooo many colors, it's understandable that some of the LE are close, if not repeats of colors under different names in new collections.
Two examples
Curiositease and Tease Me... those are sooo very close.
And the MA I was discussing this with mentioned that Tassel is really Liza Red.
Any more you can think of?

 

[MAC_Whore]

-Belle Azure=Freshwater
-As someone else mentioned: Kei lipglass is Flash of Flesh lipglass
-Womanly is soooo close to C-Thru lipglass
-Blue Storm pigment is basically Naval Blue pigment

I'm sure I could find more.....

 

[wiffa]

Well, the obvious Kicky blue, re-released as Parrot.

 

[thegirlgotsoul]

Some other good threads on this subject:

http://www.specktra.net/forum/showth...ght=freshwater

http://www.specktra.net/forum/showth...ght=freshwater

 

[Clada]

Ah! I searched and searched and never found that thread.
Thank you

 

[thegirlgotsoul]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Clada Ah! I searched and searched and never found that thread. Thank you

No problemo.

 

[Turbokittykat]

Both Fanatabulous lipglasses were rereleases of existing colours with different names, and both Asian exclusive Playboy lipsticks (not Bunny Pink but the two released later).

Also, Florabundi lipstick is very close if not identical to Madame B.

 

[tinagrzela]

Dusk Lipglass from Catherine Deneuve is the exact same thing as Pink Clash. I have both, and I've tried many ways of using them to see a difference, and never saw one.

 

[JMKess]

I'm convinced (now these are old colors here) that Melody and Pretty Twisted were the exact same shade (maybe tweaked slightly)

Jennifer

 

[roxybc]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Turbokittykat Both Fanatabulous lipglasses were rereleases of existing colours with different names, and both Asian exclusive Playboy lipsticks (not Bunny Pink but the two released later.

Bunny pink was also re-relased as Courtly. Courly was LE as well, but they are both identical.

 

[Isis]

In one of the upcoming summer collections Phosphorelle is a re-release of Elle under a slightly changed name.

 

[brokenplaything]

goldenaire and deck chair...identical
mystical mist, and au contraire...

damn...

pigments may be slightly more "something" each, but I swear, they're alike...and are also described the same in mac books.

 

[Eilinoir]

Quote:

Originally Posted by brokenplaything goldenaire and deck chair...identical

Though the swatch pic on MUA would disagree with me, I don't think they're not identical at all.
Deckchair is lighter and is a soft light pink with subtle pigmentation.
Goldenaire is a bit darker, leans toward a golden-pink, is pretty frosty and has more pigmentation.

From the outside of the containers, though, they do look very similar

 

[panties]

olive groove=greensmoke

 

[KJam]

(Original) gold (frost) pigment = golden lemon pigment

 

[Turbokittykat]

Quote:

Originally Posted by KJam (Original) gold (frost) pigment = golden lemon pigment

No way. They're similar, sure, but they are definitely not the same.

 

[ninabruja]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Turbokittykat Also, Florabundi lipstick is very close if not identical to Madame B.

and punkin!

 

[panties]

Quote:

Originally Posted by KJam (Original) gold (frost) pigment = golden lemon pigment

it's not the same...gold pigment is prettier.

 

[girlzippy]

Quote:

Originally Posted by tinagrzela Mauro Lipglass from Catherine Deneuve is the exact same thing as Pink Clash. I have both, and I've tried many ways of using them to see a difference, and never saw one.

Sorry I have to taotally disagree with that one. Pink clash is a very shimmery mid pink gold, Mauro is a barley shimmery deep pink/maroonish color. I just tested them side by side at MAC today. Dusk from Catherine Denevue is similar, but no gold

 

[mellimello]

Quote:

Originally Posted by MAC_Whore -As someone else mentioned: Kei lipglass is Flash of Flesh lipglass

Ahhh I wish something else was/is identical to Flash of Flesh. I've been driving myself crazy looking for that l/g!