Tarte Shade Recommandation Please

Hi everyone,
I've been mostly a drugstore foundation girl but lately have really wanted to try the other more high end brands, especially Tarte's Amazonian clay 12-hour full coverage foundation with SPF 15.
I've tried almost all drugstore foundations out there and the only one I can find that fits my skin tone perfectly is the ALMAY line smoothing liquid makeup in shade 140/buff.
Only problem is that I don't have a store that sells Tarte close and seeing how many shades the Tarte foundation has makes it impossible to pick the shade online.

Any advice on which shade matches my Almay foundation best?
I'd really appreciate the help!
 
Top