The best black MAC e/s?

[user2]

Yes I have no black e/s in my collection and that's why I wanna buy one tomorrow after I got my new haircolor!
But I need some opinions regarding those three in the poll so let me hear yours!

 

[Hikaru-chan]

I'd go with Black Tied, I have all 3 colors and I find Carbon can look very flat and Knight Divine looks gray on me.

 

[user3]

For a true Black ....Carbon
The other 2 have a shimmer but between those I like Black Tied.

 

[as_cute_as_pie]

knight divine isnt really a BLACK more gunmetal i would say its nice but not a black

 

[Jennifer Mcfly]

Quote:

Originally Posted by as_cute_as_pie knight divine isnt really a BLACK more gunmetal i would say its nice but not a black

ditto. knight divine isn't really a true black.
for a true black I'd go with Carbon. I really like it!

 

[Juneplum]

carbon

 

[user2]

OK ladies you were right....even my MA told me if I was looking for a black black I should go for Carbon and so I bought it!

Thanks ladies!

 

[DaizyDeath]

carbon all the way