I wear lipsticks more than lipglosses. So I have more lipstick recommendations. Some of these shaded may or may not work for you as we have different skin tones
l/s: 3N (LE), Please Me, Chatterbox, Vegas Volt, Up the Amp, Spirit, So Scarlet (LE), Lollipop Lovin' (LE), Girl About Town, Strange Hybrid (LE)
l/g: Prrr, See Thru, Sock Hop (LE), Cult of Cherry (LE), Pink Grapefruit (LE), Soft n Slow (LE), Steppin Out dazzleglass (LE), Love Alert dazzleglass (LE)
i love lipsticks and lipgloss!!
my favorites so far are
lipsticks: Back to Del Rio, Tease Me, 5N, Destined, Budding Lust, Mouse Slimshine, Pleasing, Viva Glam V, Charismatic, Full Blown
Lipgloss: Atmospheric, Love Nectar, Joyberry, Revealing, Instant Gold lustreglass, Little VI, Jellicious, sappilicious, Beaux, Angel Wing
1. Fresh Brew
2. Brave
3. Viva Glam V
4. magenta lipline(i use this as lipstick)
5. pomposity
6. capricious
7. 40's pink from the mattene
8. carnal (discontinued) my fav red
9. hig tea
10. bouy-o-bouy
LIPGLOSSES
1. Pink patina (l/v)
2. Lilycrush lip gelee
3. Wondershine 3D lipglass
4. Perfectly pink l/g
5. Real desire l/g
6. and all the victoria secret ones, and the bath and body bigelow ones
Unfortunately, for me, many of MAC's products that I love most seem to be limited edition or otherwise get discontinued. I'm also partial to lipglosses. Here's some lip stuff I really like:
Lipsticks:
So Scarlet*
Queen's Sin*
Lovemate*
O
Siren*
Miss Dish*
Lipglasses/Lustreglasses:
Happening Gal*
Light My Fire*
New Flame*
Cult of Cherry*
Lil' Hot Pepper*
Pink Grapefruit*
Pop Mode
Red Romp*
Venetian
Sex Ray*
Ornamental
Pinkarat
Star Nova