Top 15 MAC eye shadows

[banana1234]

Question. Do you ladies feel that MAC eyeshadows last a long time or would I need a primer(?) underneath to keep the color from fading & creasing?
Also, any color(s) that are similar to a perwinkle (blue-lavender-lilac)? I heard that winkle is a very nice periwinkle shade, but it looks very blue to me.
Thanks for your help!

winkle is very blue, so not what u want really, not sure on a periwinkle shade for u though

and yes, you do definitely need a primer with mac shades to keep them vibrant and prevent creasing, i recommend urban decay's primer potion

 

[lipglossmafia]

Here are my picks

1. Ricepaper
2.Bronze
3.Cranberry
4.Stars and Rockets
5.Amberlights
6.Expensive Pink
7.Bisque
8.Deep Truth
9.Humid
10.Contrast
11.Gold Mine
12.Sketch
13.Shadowy lady
14.embark
15. RULE <---dont forget Rule its awesome

 

[CremeDeLaReyna]

My Top 15 in no particular order...

1. Cork
2. Brulee
3. Patina
4. Satin Taupe
5. Naked Lunch
6. Woodwinked
7. Carbon
8. Electric Eel
9. Black Tied
10. Print
11. Steamy
12. Hepcat
13. Arena
14. Kicky Blue
15. Orange

 

[biancastefani]

I'm definitely a neutral-kinda-gal, but the shades are all so pretty and different!

1. Shroom (frost)
2. Orb (satin)
3. Kid (veluxe)
4. Cork (satin)
5. Brown Down (veluxe)
6. Copperplate (matte2)
7. Romp (frost)
8. Sable (frost)
9. Satin Taupe (frost)
10. Patina (frost)
11. Era (satin)
12. Woodwinked (veluxe pearl)
13. Mulch (velvet)
14. All That Glitters (veluxe pearl)
15. Soba (satin)

 

[lilysaville]

In no particular order:

1. Blanc Type
2. Carbon
3. Soot (PRO, try Print if you can't get to a PRO store. They're virtually the same colour, except Soot is matte and Print is satin.)
4. Concrete
5. Satin Taupe
6. Sable
7. Omega (Great universal brow shade, transition colour and contour for eye and face on pale girls. So versatile IMO.)
8. Gorgeous Gold
9. Henna (LE, try Sumptuous Olive maybe?)
10. Humid
11. Juxt
12. Shale
13. Crystal Avalanche
14. Prussian
15. 100 Strokes (LE, try Twinks maybe?)

Whew, that was hard!

 

[madeinbrklyn]

I tried to stay in the permanent line..

Blanc Type
Sketch
All That Glitters
Crystal Avalanche
Stars and Rockets
Sweet and Punchy (LE, try Lucky Green, it isn't an exact dupe.)
Naked Lunch
Cranberry
Espresso
Patina
Atlantic Blue (I line my lower lash line with this for a pop of color.)
Omega
Woodwinked
Soft Brown
Chrome Yellow

 

[HappyInsomniac]

All That Glitters.
Quarry.
Satin Taupe.
Sable.
Tempting.
Trax.
Plumage.
Gulf Stream.
Springtime Skipper.
Humid.
Lucky Green.
Strike a Pose.
Contrast.

Beauty Marked.
Nocturnelle.

 

[makeupishaute]

Brulé
Omega
Ricepaper
Shadowy Lady
Hepcat
Chrome Yellow
All that Glitters
Handwritten
Greensmoke
Club
Carbon
Sketch
Yogurt
Embark
Tete-a-tint



Love those shades. This is my first post btw!

 

[Adee]

Banshee Star & rockets Hepcat Seedy pearl Mulch Kid Shroom Beautiful iris Aquadisiac Swish Vellum Trax Naked Lunch Girlie Club Wow! That was harder than I thought it would be! I especially love banshee and trax. Kid is a great transition color for your crease. Girlie goes with almost anything!:eyelove:

 

[sgr2008]

Hi !
I recommend you take an appointment with a Mac counter artist and try lots of fun colors, you would be surprised as sometimes the strangest colors in the pans can look soo good on the eyes !
For me, the neutral/everyday colors I could not live without are :
Carbon
Satin taupe
Sable
Vex
Patina
Haux
Shale
Mystery
Sketch
All that glitters
Brule
Print

Have fun !

 

[Anna x]

1.vanilla 2. ricepaper 3.allthatglitters 4.woodwinked 5.sable 6.espresso 7.trax 8.sketch 9.parfait amour 10.cranberry 11.humid 12.mulch 13.antiqued 14.satin taupe 15.naked lunch

 

[Habbakuk]

1. all that glitters
2. naked lunch
3. woodwinked
4. ricepaper
5. sumptuous olive
6. humid
7. brule
8. expensive pink
9. carbon
10. satin taupe
11. print
12. contrast
13. deep truth
14. stars n rockets
15. beautiful iris

 

[MrsKLV]

Lol! I was thinking of doing the same thing until I saw your post. Are you a Virgo by any chance? Hehe!

 

[MrsKLV]

Sorry. Was replying to the girl who made a spreadsheet.

 

[alexandrapalaci]

I would get...
1.humid
2.carbon
3.club
4.patina
5.plumage
6.copperplate
7.cranberry
8.gulfstream
9.humid
10.greensmoke
11.phloof
12.lucky green
13.satin taupe
14.ricepaper
15.sketch

 

[shklnyk]

I love...

Phloof!
Satin Taupe
Bronze
Goldmine
Amber Lights
Vanilla
Cork
Deep Truth
Trax
Vex
Beautiful Iris
Tilt
Humid
Carbon
Smut

 

[anna82]

patina
satin taupe
shale
era
esresso
all that glitters
romp
jest
soba
sketch
smut
mystery
kid
brula

 

[anna82]

patina
satin taupe
shale
era
esresso
all that glitters
romp
jest
soba
sketch
smut
mystery
kid
brule

 

[pjendrinal]

In no particular order

Shock-A-Holic (LE)
Raving Mad (LE)
Chrome Yellow
Vibrant Grape (Pro)
Ricepaper
Humid
Freshwater
Three Ring Yellow (LE)
Plumage
Paradisco
Satin Taupe
Woodwinked
Fig 1.
Passionate
Soft Brown

 

[rubytitania]

My top picks from the permanent line (in no particular order) would be: 1. Satin Taupe 2. Vex 3. Patina 4. Club 5. Lucky Green 6. Sumptuous Olive 7. Humid 8. Phloof 9. Shale 10. Wedge 11. Naked Lunch 12. Nocturnelle 13. Shimmermoss 14. Vanilla 15. Sable I also like Twinks, Brule, Trax, Steamy, Handwritten, Copperplate, Romp, Beautiful Iris, Jest, Goldmine, Mulch, Crystal and more, but those are my favourites I'm NW15-ish with red hair and green eyes, for reference.