I like unusual fragrances with food-y smells, the fragrances I wear most are:-
Kenzo Jungle - spices on a licquorice base, v. unusual, all time fave.
Fyrrinae: Cherry Ice Cream Smile- cherries and vanilla. Cheap, too!
Fyrinnae: Mango Lemon - clean, fresh but sweet, too.
Lush: Ginger - roses and, well yes, lots of ginger.
These ALWAYS get compliments and nobody ever recognises them. Men always notice the 2 spicy ones, women comment on the 2 sweet ones more.
I also wear Clinique Aromatics when the mood strikes, but its a very recognisable one, and I have to be feeling uber-vamp to pull off something so very, very spic-eh.
There's also another Fyrinnae one (Chocolatl I think?) that I really like to wear, chocolate, spices and a touch of nutty coffee. I would heartily recommend trying Fyrinnae's perfume oils, they're like $1.75 for a sample vial, too.