which formal black palette for a present?

[~Crystal~]

I really want to give one of the formal black eyeshadow palettes to a friend for her birthday present, but I need to buy it soon

Thing is, I don't know which one to get her!! I keep leaning towards the warm palette, but that's probably because I really like it...
I've posted a photo of us, though the lighting isn't too great

I'm to the left, and she's in the middle next to me.
Which palette (cool, warm or smoked) do you girls think would be best for her?
thank you!

Edit: posting another pic- she's in the middle again

 

[prinzessin784]

I think the Smoked palette is the best way to go if you're giving it as a gift. It's the most versatile and it can work for pretty much everyone. I hope that helps!

Whichever one you get though I'm sure she'll love it! How could she not?!

 

[Kiseki]

I would say the cool eye palette.

 

[Kat]

i would say smoked eye for the same reasons as above

 

[MAC_ATTACK]

I would say the smoked eye. Most universal of the 4.

 

[HayleyVengeance]

smoked !

 

[cherrycola]

Smoked IS pretty versatile from what I can see!

 

[fairytale22]

I love the smoked but I think the warm would be a good choice too!

 

[Glitziegal]

I would go warm. Why? Because the colours are great and not all available as singles.