Which smokey eyes palette is best?

[zeroxstar]

1. Holiday '06 - Velvet 6 Smoked Eyes Holiday 2006
Eyeshadows: Malt, Vex, Satin Taupe, Club, Gentle Fume, and Black Tie

2. Holiday '07 - Royal Assets: 6 Smokey Eyes
Eyeshadows: Maid of Honor, Rondelle, Palatial, Courtly Grey, Majestic, and Knight

3. Holday '08 - Passions of Red: 6 Smokey Eyes
Eyeshadows: Scant, Satin Taupe, Dark Devotion, Gorgeous, Ambiance, and Carbon

 

[Ms. Z]

I'm glad you posted this, but now it's gonna drive me crazy; I have the 2006 & 2007 and I'm so tempted to buy this years.

Does anyone have all 3, I'd like to see pictures of all 3 side to side?

 

[gigiopolis]

I don't have the 06 or 07 ones but I have to say that this year's smokey eye palette is pure perfection. So many different looks you could do with it, and I really feel like it represents the most basic, classic smokey eye possible. Great for beginners who want something to start off with, and still great for non-beginners because it's such a nice concise group of 6 wonderful smokey eye colours. I use all of the colours in the palette (sometimes in a palette you have maybe one or two colours you don't exactly love, but not the case with this one).

Can you tell I loooove my palette?

 

[xxManBeaterxx]

Last years smokey pallette was good. But this years is absolutely amazing

 

[Ms. Z]

You guys are killing me, now I am more tempted than ever. Don't any of you have comparison photos?