Pass. The only thing that really impressed me in this collection was the lip pencil. I swatched a couple on the back of my hand last night and they went on extremely creamy and smooth, like a pearlglide eyeliner, I heard someone else say, and that is so true. And on top of that, these things immediately set and stay on. They stayed on through washing my face last night, and through my shower this morning. I ultimately removed them with eye makeup remover. The shadows were dupable and I'm turned off of the glosses by all the negative talk about them. I will probably investigate the lipcremes a bit more down the road.