Your pigment collection and how they rate?

[askewchick]

What pigments do you have and how do they rate?

Tan (***) - a little too sheer for my liking, but a nice neutral.
Melon (****) - I prefer this as a highlighter as it adds a subtle golden cast.
Frost (**) - Not bad, but very glittery!
Violet (*****) - Love this! A nice shimmery bright purple that isn't too dark!
Grape (****) - A great liner color when used wet!
Maroon (****) - Same as Grape.
Blue (*****) - This is an awesome bright shimmery blue that reminds me of Freshwater e/s.
Green (*****) - The only true mid-green I've found with suitable shimmer that isn't too dark.
Gold (*****) - I love this as a wash because it has a yellow tone instead of being metal.
Kitschmas (***) - A change from the usual creamy colored highlighters.
Blue Brown (****) - This is nice as a multi-dimensional liner.
Golden Olive (*****) - A gem! This is one of the best out there!
Pink Opal (*****) - I like this as a highlighter with any cool toned shadows.
Pink Pearl (****) - This rocks because it is completely unlike any other shadow or shadestick.
Vanilla (*****) - A great neutral highlighter that can be paired with anything.
Old Gold (*****) - Very nice green tarnished mid-gold.
Fairylite (***) - A neutral satin with some glitter in it for oomph!

Waiting for Steel Blue, Coco Beach, Rose, Kelly Green and White Gold in swaps!

 

[user2]

Golden Olive (****): The first pigment I've bought, amazing green and gold!
Bright Fuchsia (***/2): Very intense color, only great for a liner or inner crease
Old Gold (****): Great as well, although I just have a sample I use it almoste everyday
White Frost (***): Good use as a highlghter on the brow bone but too simple for me!
Melon (****): Not received yet but when my MA used it on me it looked fantabulous ;-)
Copper Sparkle (*****): Mhh i looove it! It makes my eyes pop!

 

[mymymai]

White Gold (**) Okay, not really outstanding
Vanilla (****) Great highlighter
Frost (*****) I adore this color. Glitter gets everywhere, but it is worth it!
Pink Opal (*) Not enough flash (opal flash)
Farylite (1/2) Not really liking this one
Melon (***) Nice color for work
Old Gold (*****) You'd have to pry this out of my cold dead hands first
Gold (*****) Love the color, application, everything!
Green Olive (*****) Again, very nice. Beautiful color.
True Chartreuse (****) Nice bright color, but I don't like texture
Yellow (**) Bright, but no one of my favorites
Red (***) Nice bright red...too bad it isn't eye safe
Bright Fuchsia (****) Great color, but I have reactions to this color
Pink (**) Plain pink, nothing spectacular.
Pink Pearl (*****) Superb color, another I'd take to the grave with me.
All Girl (**) Cute but doesn't go on easily to give intensity seen in jar.
Rose (****) Lovely color
Violet (*****) Perfect purple for me (NW20)
French Violet (**) Nice color, but again, don't like the texture
Steel Blue (**) Okay color, but hard to pair it with others
Clear Blue Sky (****) Spectacular color
Dark Soul (*) meh
Black (**) Decent black
Platinum (*****) Beautiful bright color, goes on so smoothly.
Copper (*****) Beautiful bright color, goes on so smoothly.
Rich Purple (**) A little too dark
Landscape Green (*) Unremarkable green
Deep Blue Green (***) Nice color, but a little dark
Pink Bronze (**) Pretty, but doesn't really do it for me
Burnt Burgundy (*) meh
Royal Blue (****) Spectacular color, just stunning
Ruby Red (*****) I adore this color. It works so well with my skintone.
Kitschmas (*) Too much hype
Grape (**) Pretty, but can make one look bruised
Deep Purple (*) okay
Acid Orange (****) Luv it and its dual color
Golden Lemon (**) Nice, but awfully messy
Chartreuse (****) Love the brightness of the color, but not the texture
Teal (***) Pretty
Kelly Green (*****) Lovely green with just enough sparkle
Blue Storm (***) Nice, but too close to Naval Blue
Naval Blue (***) Nice
Cornflower (*****) Excellent dual chromatic blue

 

[Juneplum]

Tan (*****) LOVE THIS

Pink Opal (***) Pretty
Fairylite (***) Pretty
Melon (*****) ONE OF MY FAVES

Old Gold (*****) LOVE THIS
Gold (*****) LOVE IT
Green Olive (*****) LOVE IT
Bright Fuchsia (****) Very pretty color
Pink (**) Meaahh... it's ok.
Pink Pearl (*****) ONE OF MY FAVES

All Girl (***) I only use this lips only
Rose (*****) ONE OF MY FAVES

Violet (*****) Near perfect purple
Clear Blue Sky (****) Outrageously pretty
Dark Soul (****) love it
Copper Sparkle (*****) ONE OF MY FAVES

Deep Blue Green (****) LOVE IT
Pink Bronze (****) Pretty
Ruby Red (*****) ONE OF MY FAVES

Kitschmas (**) it's ok...
Teal (****) Pretty
Kelly Green (*****) FAB green
Blue Storm (*****) my FAVORITE blue

Cornflower (*****) LOVE IT!!
Coco Beach (*****) LOVE THIS!!
Chocolate Brown (****) love it
Blue Brown (*****) so unique

 

[Sanne]

Frost(*) Pretty in the pot, but doesn't do anything on my eyes
All girl(****)Love it! It's a super shiny pink
Blue(***) Love the color, but I don't use it that much
Chartreuse(****)AMAZING color!
Coco beach(**)Nice, but I don't use it that much
Cornflower(*)Weird color, not eye safe..I'm glad I got a free sample of this
Fuchsia(****)I lovelovelove this true frosted fuchsia color, to bad the stayingpower isn't all that
Golden olive(****)amazing color, I should be using more!
Golden lemon(**)If this would be eyesafe, I would use this alot more. Will put this in my blond hair this summer!
Kitschmas(***)beautifull, but I end up using it very little!
Melon(***)Not really my color. Great pigmentation though!
Old gold(**)This looks terrible on me!
Pink Bronze(**)I can't pull of bronze, I'm glas this was a free sample
Rose(*)Love the color, but I hate the texture...I cannot get this on well!
Tan(***)can be used for everything, because the color is so normal!
Teal(***)I hate it that this one isn't eyesave, it so gorgeous!
Vanilla(**)too gold as a highlighter, too light as a shadow
Violet(*****)MY ALLTIME FAVORITE PIGMENT!
White gold(**)Hate it, I don't like it as a shadow, and I detest it as a highlighter!

 

[Shawna]

pink opal - love it, use it all the time
rose - love it use it especially on my cheeks (it did go kind of clumpy in its container though?)
fairylite - loved it until I found out it wasn't eye safe. Still use it on my cheeks and for highlighting. I guess I'll have to get the new safe formulation

I have a vial of coco beach from the christmas collection that I have only tested once. It is too dark for me. I am not allowed to trade yet, but will trade for sure once I can.

 

[ladybugz07]

Well, I got my first pigment about 5 years ago (Frost)... I was kinda out of the pigment loop, until this past Christmas. So, with the exception of Frost, I have amassed all these pigments in the past 5 months...

All Girl (*****) I love it so much I bought a spare
Kitschmas (***) Didn't think it was quite worth the hype
Rose (*****) One of the most versatile pigments, IMO
Fuchsia (****) Great bright pink
Bright Fuchsia (****) Got a sample & love it, I NEED a jar now
Fairylite (**) Kinda blah
Violet (*****) Violet really makes blue eyes pop, so I bought a spare
Frost (**) My very 1st pigment, I've had for over 5 years
Pink Opal (***) Very subtle
White Gold (***) Very subtle
Dark Soul (***) Great for a smokey eye
Maroon (***) Pretty, but very dark
Melon (***) Great natural color
Tan (***) Great natural color
Blue Brown (**) This is so neat, but I'm not into browns
Vanilla (***) A great highlighter
Golden Olive (**) Pretty, not my color, personally
Old Gold (***) Very neat color, don't know what to pair it with
Teal (****) Just got this and love the color, haven't played with too much
Deep Purple (****) Much more frosty than people said, I like it
Grape (****) This one is sparkly & very dense
Deep Blue Green (***) Neat color, very, very dark
Steel Blue (*****) Great blue, gold sparkle like Rose
Blue Storm (**) A bit too dark and blah for me
Blue (*****) Love it, had to buy a spare
Kelly Green (****) Like it much more than I thought I would
Frozen White (****) I like the blue/violet sheen to this one
Coco Beach (***) Like I said, I'm not into browns
Cornflower (****) A very pretty blue, not too dark
Pink Bronze (***) Interesting color, too orangy for me
Gold (**) I haven't found a great use for this one, but I'm trying
Ruby Red (****) love it, but why can't MAC have a truly vivid (frosty) red pigment???
Pink Pearl (*****) Oh I love it, I only have a sample & NEED much more
Copper Sparkle (****) I like this one, great sparkle
Silver (****) Metallics rock
Platinum (****) Metallics rock
Copper (**) Metallics rock, although this one less than others
Naked (*) Got a sample and will *not* get a jar of this one, so blah

Some of my pigment collection...
http://img.makeupalley.com/8/2/8/6/297606.jpeg

 

[jamiemeng]

rose- one of my faves

 

[bballgirl612]

WOW, I have a teenie tiny collection compared to all of you!!
Emerald Green(****) Beautiful but can be a little to dark
Old Gold(*****) GEORGEOUS!
Fairylite(****) Great Highlighter, a little to shimmery

 

[banana]

I have a very small collection too:

Tan(*****) one of my favourite makeup products PERIOD.
Silver(*****) a must-have gunmetal grey, especially if you have dark brown eyes
Pink Opal(****) adds OOMPH to smokey eye looks
Blue Storm(***) nice but I don't use it much- glad I only have a sample
Vanilla(**) so blah on me. oh well it was a free sample

 

[MizBrightFuture]

Another tiny collection
Chartreuse(*****)-This is a pretty light green
Tan(****)-this is a beautiful neutral
Vanilla(***)-This is a nice highlight but i cant get highlights to work right for me
Pink bronze(****)-This is pretty a orangy pink
Old gold(****)-this isn't gold,its a green that flashes bronze on me

 

[claresauntie]

I couldn't even go through them all and list them!
My faves are the Pro Metals (all of them), Black Black, Subtle and MELON.

I am also really interested in the new Danse piggies. I haven't played with them too much, but they seem to be similar to what I like in Melon (which mostly has to do with their versatility on different colors of skin).

 

[geeko]

wow u girls have a lot of pigments...here goes mine

Azreal blue (*** - i wished it had less silver glitters in it and they were not so chunky)
Accent Red (**** pretty but can't wear it everyday)
Apricot Pink (***** Very pretty. Can be used as cheek color too)
Blue Storm (Haven really worn this color yet so i can't comment)
Chocolate Brown (***** A very nice shade of chocolatey brown)
Cornflower (Jus bought the full bottle of it. Haven tried it)
Dazzleray (***** A great neutral color )
Entremauve (***** A fantastic dark purple shade...easy to blend)
Fuschia (**** Nice but not very wearable)
Fairylite (*** it's just okay for me only)
Golden Lemon (***** VERY nice. A MUST have. Love this)
Golden Olive (***** My favourite green pigment from MAC)
Golder's Green (***** Another great shade of green..looks a bit like golden olive, but golden olive has more golden undertones to it)
Gold dusk (***** very versatile)
Lovely lily (**** a nice wearable purple)
Lily White ( ***** a great neutral color)
Melon (***** My HG highlighter)
NightLight (***** A very nice smoky green pigment)
Naked (*** nothing special about this)
Old gold (**** Unique color)
Pink Bronze (**** A unique color)
Pinked Mauve (***** PRETTY)
Pastorale (***** A very nice shade of pastel green)
Subtle (***** Fantastic texture and color)
Sunnydaze (**** It's nice but i wish there were less chunky glitter)
Shimmertime (***** A great highlighter or eyewash)
Softwash grey (***** very nice violet-grey pigment)
Teal (***** A must have for all teal/turqoise lovers)
Tan (**** quite a nice shade of neutral color)
Rose (*** The glitters are too chunky, hard to blend)
Vanilla (***** Very versatile)

 

[MiCHiE]

Deep Blue Green (*****) I love this with Teal Pig. on the lid for a fab smokey eye.

Blue (***) I love this color, but it only got 3 stars 'cause I never wear it.

Tan (*****) This is my favorite pigment. I wear it almost daily. I've dropped it on the floor and scooped it back up with business cards because I adore it so much (maybe I should just get a back up, eh?)

Softwash Grey/sample (****) I read about this color all the time with blues....I've gotten so many compliments on it with other purples.

Apricot Pink/sample (*****) I really should get a full size of this one. I wear it A LOT. My fave. combo with it? Apricot Pink on lid, Tan Pigment on inner V, faded into crease, Mulch on Crease, A little Brown Down to the outer V and Retrospeck to highlight.

Fuschia/sample (****) Not worn much, but I love it when I do.

Teal (*****) LOVE THIS!!!

Blue Brown (*) Recommended by my MUA. Totally not into it.

Pinked Mauve (***) Very pretty color, but I reach for Apricot Pink Pigment more.

Accent Red/sample (****) Love this color, but I have yet to wear it.

 

[baby_love]

-Electric Coral(**)hardly shows up unless you use a base
-Subtle(*****)such an awesome neutralish color that can be played up or played down depending on what you pair it with.
-Golden Olive(*****)such a beautiful color, and goes on very easilly.
-Golder's Green(*****)very beautiful color that's unique.
-Night Light(*****)I use this practically everyday!
-Shimmertime(*****)This makes for a wonderful highlighter on the cheeks and eyes.
-Ruby Red(****)Even though it's not eyesafe, I still use it there. that's my only gripe about it though. but it's also a great lip color! one of my favorite pigments.
-Pink Pearl(****)I wish it went on more pigmented, it has a good texture but on me, it goes on a little sheer. I have to use hush ccb to get it to the color in the jar.
-Steel Blue(***)one of my favorite blue colors, but unfortunately, goes on like SHIT! if you use mixing medium it goes on, but even with hush ccb, it doesn't go on like the jar. it has to be wet I guess.
-Softwash Grey(***)it's a nice color, but has an odd texture.
-Gold Dusk(*****)SO AMAZING! it goes with pretty much every color, and it's a wonderful cheek highlighter!
-Dazzleray(***)it's a wonderful color, but goes on a little light and grainy for me.
-Pinked Muave(***)it has a good texture and goes on pigmented, but the color is lacking in something, and i can't figure out what haha.
-Aire-de-Blu(*****)wonderful light blue. so soft and wonderful as a wash.
-Apricot Pink(****)nice color, but I never really use it haha.
-Lily White(**)weird texture and doesn't go on very well, too white.
-Lovely Lily(*****)wonderful light purple!!

 

[blueglitter]

Lovely Lily(***) Not enough colour for me
Goldenaire(****) LOVE IT
Vanilla(*****)Great base colour for me
Golden Olive(****)Makes my eyes stand out
Cornflower(**)Doesnt really suit my eye colour
White Gold(*****)BEAUTIFUL
Teal(*****)LOVE IT

 

[asnbrb]

oh, god. mine's kinda long. I'm doing it on word right now.

eta: first part-
accent red (***) makes a nice lip, but exactly like ruby red (pro)
acid orange (***) it’s a great color, nowhere to really wear it
all girl (*) I do NOT see the attraction to this damn color. Doesn’t show up, looks bleagh
apricot pink (****) This is awesome. I’m so glad that I have a jar. I’m big on a lazy day eye and this makes it so easy
azrael blue (****) loses a point just because I don’t look as good in this as the greens in the same collection (haha) very good, though
basic red (**) again, like turquoise and honestly, it’s not that red
black (***) nice deep black, but carbon is much easier to work with
blue (rr) (***) loses points because it looks just like freshwater on me, but it’s a nice, bright color
blue brown (****) great duochrome over black
blue storm (***) it’s OKAY. Nothing more, really
bright coral (****) nice color, but I don’t really have anywhere to wear it!
bright fuchsia (****)Great, bright color, but I don’t think it’s eyesafe
burnt burgundy (**) hard to work with IMHO and comes out quite muddy
chartreuse (***) great popping color, but I need a base and to slightly work at it
chocolate brown (***) it’s alright, but nothing real fancy
coco (****) isn’t there two other colors just like this? Loses a point, but it’s pretty high because it’s a HG for everyday wear
coco beach (****) great, deep brown, but I could probably do without (don’t wanna, though)
copper sparkle (****) this makes a great liner when mixed with eyeliner MM.
copperclast (****) one of them HGs again. Great in a crease
cornflower (***) really haven’t found anything to do with this yet
dark soul (*****) yeah, you know that a shadow would be easier, but this blends so nicely and looks great with a smoky eye
dazzleray (*****) perfect daytime eye when you really don’t want to do anything. HG
deckchair (****) loses a point for lack of originality, but it’s a HG nonetheless
deep blue green (***) oh, so pretty in the pot. So muddy on my eye
deep purple (***) looks a little muddy on me
emerald green (*****) great jewel toned color. I love this
entremauve (****) makes my brown eyes pop, but exactly like grape (pro)
fairylite (***) kinda eh. nothing really pops for me with this one
frost (***) nice highlight, but too shimmery for my taste
fuchsia (****) I honestly didn’t expect to like this so much, but it just makes the best alternative liner EVAR
gold dusk (*****) oh, so pretty. Nice, cool color
golden lemon (***) pretty, but honestly I can’t figure out how to wear this without making me look jaundiced
golden olive (****) lovely

 

[asnbrb]

goldenaire (****) HG and it’s nice and light, but somehow makes my eyes look polished. Loses a point because there’s deckchair and it’s almost like it
golder's green (****) awesome, unique color. Makes my brown eyes pop
grape (*****) HG despite looking exactly like entremauve. Makes my brown eyes pop like nothing else
green brown (*****) lovely over black liner
kelly green (**) loses so many points because of the unworkability of the texture
kitchmas (**) bleagh. It’s too damn shimmery and falls everywhere
lily white (**) ugh. So sparkly. Makes my eyebrows pop (haha) because it’s just so out there when I put it on
lovely lily (*****) surprised me so much on how workable this is. This is the perfect amount of light color and texture.
marine ultra (***) honestly, I just bought this “just because I didn’t have it”. Nothing really poppy or anything
melon (*****) just the perfect amount of shimmer and the duochrome looks fantastic
naked (**) really. You look naked wearing it. What’s the point?
nightlight (*****) excellent for a smoky green eye and easy to work with
old gold (**) kinda makes me look a little jaundiced, but it’s a nice color
pink bronze (**) honestly, I don’t wear it that much. Makes my eyelids look a little tired
pink opal (****) shimmery and slightly duochromed
pink pearl (****) excellent duochrome and great over black liner
pinked mauve (****) I use this in the corners of my eye. Nice for a slightly smoky eye
platinum (metal) (***) excellent, but loses points for being a metal and not eyesafe
primary yellow (**) lovely color, crappy texture
rose (****) makes a great lippie and blush, but loses a point because of the texture
ruby red (***) great lip, just like accent red
silver fog (***) I’ve got so many other silvers that are easier to work with
silver metal (***) same as platinum metal. I wish they made it eyesafe
softwash grey (*****) great just to add a little emphasis
steel blue (****) great color, shitty texture (but workable if you mash it into your brush)
subtle (****) loses a point because there are so many others like it
sunnydaze (*****) one of my HGs. nice neutral for a lazy day
tan (****) sounds boring, really isn’t
teal (****) gorgeous color
turquoise (**) lovely color, crappy texture
vanilla (*****) lovely highlight
violet (****) nice and easy to work with
white (***) honestly, completely forgot that I owned a sample. It’s nice and beautifully shimmery. Would make a great highlight
white gold (***) it’s alright, but I fail to see the gold when I put it on

 

[mellimello]

All Girl (*) - I can't stand this color. Way too glittery. Glad I just got rid of mine. Definitely not worth the hype.
Apricot Pink (**) - Pretty color but isn't true to life on my skin.
Azreal Blue (****) - A gorgeous blue that is light and airy!
Bright Fuchsia (***) - Pretty but sucks that it's not "eye safe"
Coco Beach (*****) - LOVELOVELOVE!! lol
Emerald Green (****) - The consistency isn't the best but I LOVE the color.
Deckchair (*****) - My HG pigment. Best highlight ever imo.
Gold Dusk (*****) - Great as a highlight or as a base to make colors brighter.
Goldenaire (****) - Too close to Deckchair but pretty nonetheless.
Golders Green (***) - Average green, nothing special.
Lily White (**) - Hate the consistency, the color is ok.
Lovely Lily (***) - Nice color but I'm not a big fan of the pigment.
Pinked Mauve (**) - Meh. That's all I can say about this one lol.
Ruby Red (*****) - This is great on the lips and it's one of the only pink/purple hues I can pull off on my eyes.
Softwash Grey (****) - Love this color, wish I used it more.
Sunnydaze (****) - Perfect neutral brown.
Vanilla (***) - Nice highlight but is a little too gray/green based to use all the time. Makes good corpse makeup though! lol

 

[bruinshorty]

oh my this is going to take forever....

Accent Red (****)
All Girl (****)
Apricot Pink (*****) fave
Azreal Blue (***)
Blue Storm (??) haven't used it yet
Bright Fuschia (??) haven't used it yet
Burnt Burgandy (***)
Chartreuse (****)
Chocolate Brown (*****) fave
Coco (*****)
Cool Pink (***)
Copper Sparkle (***)
Deckchair (****)
Deep Brown (***)
Deep Purple (*****) fave
Dazzleray (****)
Dusty Coral (**)
Electric Coral (??) haven't used it yet
Fairylite (***)
French Violet (****)
Frozen White (***)
Fuschia (*****)
Gold Dusk (*****) fave
Gold Metal (****)
Golden Lemon (****) my first MAC item :')
Golden Olive (*****)
Goldenaire (*****) fave
Golder's Green (****)
Grape (*****) fave
Green Brown (*****)
Kelly Green (****)
Kitchmas (2nd release) (***)
Lily White (***)
Lovely Lily (*****) fave
Melon (*****) fave
Night Light (****)
Nocturnal Plum (***)
Old Gold (****)
Pink (***)
Pink Bronze (*****)
Pink Opal (*****)
Pink Pearl (*****)
Pink Vivid (***)
Pinked Mauve (*****) fave
Polished Ivory (**)
Provence (**)
Rich Purple (****)
Rose (*****)
Rose Gold (***)
Ruby Red (****)
Shimmertime (*****)
Softwash Grey (*****)
Sunpepper (***)
Tan (*****)
Teal (*****)
Vanilla (*****) fave
Violet (*****) fave
White (****)
White Gold (***)

these are all samples, I don't own a full jar of anything

I'm still waiting on Subtle, Entremauve, Copperclast, and Pastorale.