Quote:Originally Posted by
katred
That's what I thought. There are certainly products I've seen mentioned a lot more even within the three categories they chose. (Queen's Sin anyone?)
I'm annoyed a bit by CYY as well, because even though lots of people want it, there are plenty of fairly close shades and it just doesn't seem that special including things we've just seen for this collection. I was even more surprised to see Emancipation on there. I hadn't really heard too many rave reviews and I didn't think that most of the WW collection even sold that well. I think there are some older items they could have brought back. I am happy to see that there are some old classics, though.
I would be surprised if those three didn't make it. My guess is that MB is a lock.
Personally, I would love to see what they do with Rocker. It was a "velvet" format lipstick, I believe it was called. It was like a matte base with sparkles in it- a bit grittier than a frost. Interesting effect, although not the most forgiving. I had a deep purple one that I used to wear a lot. I'm guessing that if they bring Rocker back (and I really hope they do), they'll have updated the formula as well.
Laughed when I saw Eden Rocks, because although it debuted in 2001, it was part of the permanent line forever and it only got discontinued within the last year or two up here... It's like they have overstock on their hands.
There is a photo of Rocker in MAC's twitter feed. It looks hot! I don't seen any glitter so hopefully the formula has changed a bit. I forgot all about Emancipation, it wasn't memorable, neither was Icescape from Love Lace. The whole Love Lace collection was not all that! I don't remember any real gems from that one. Cool Heat was at the CCO for months maybe even a year before I hauled it. Seems like we are voting on a mix of duds and cult classics... Time will tell what prevails. Hopefully the good ones will make it back during the voting process... Seriously I wouldn't be surprised if they all came back. The amount of colors in the running are about the same amount in a regular MAC collection. Real talk, I am waiting for a favorite quad re release. That would be one hell of a collection.