I bought the mascara, Catharina Lipstick, and Gesina Lipstick.
Out of the two lip colors, I adored "Gesina" the most. While the lipstick color collection isn't unique, this color was the most unique to me. It is such a pretty red with pink undertones. I wouldn't say it is fuchsia , just a red-pink. The lipsticks are a cream finish. A slight sheen, but it feels somewhat creamy on the lips, still feels more like a matte lipstick but not too drying like one.
Catharina can easily be duped color wise, while I'm sure "Gesina" can, but I buy a lot of fuchsia/red lip colors and "Gesina" I personally can't think of a lipstick color that I have already that looks like it.
For the Mascara:
I like it. My eyelashes are already uber long, and have a curl naturally. I have a fair amount of lashes, but still need volume.
This mascara does great at giving length. It also defines the lashes to almost a pin thin type look, yet adds some volume.
I guess you could say it makes the lashes look like the false lashes that are really thin and long, but not voluminous.
I really like the wand and how one swipe, maybe two is all you need to get the mascara's effect.
I've only tried from MAC Zoom Lash, Haught and Naughty, and this one. I'd say "Zoom" is a good everyday mascara for an overall lash look, but my fave is "Haught and naughty", because I can use the define wand that's pretty close to this one in look of lashes (not as dark or pin thin long), and then the "Naughty" wand for a ton of volume and to darken the lashes a lot.