MAC - Peacocky discussion

Face2Mac

Well-known member
After looking at Karla's swatches, I couldn't take Temper Tantra off my list fast enough. I won't wear that; much too dark for my taste. However, Super is looking good to me again. With the natural color of my lips, I think Super is a good nude for me.
Yeah, I was doing a side eye at you when you mentioned you loved temper tantra. I was thinking that is not going to work not straight out the box for you but what do I know, I am still getting Peacocky.
 

shontay07108

Well-known member
Today I wore Nightmoth liner with Hang Up lipstick and it looks just like Love Peck. I love Hang Up, but I don't get around to it often, so I don't need the same color again. Exxxhibitionist maybe similar to Viva Cyndi but that's fine by me because I was going to buy another Cyndi anyway so that I wouldn't run out. That is my kind of color and I reach for it often. Besides Exxx seems a bit bolder and more pigmented.

I'm going to get Noir Plum and I want Centre Stage now, but the price is making me hesitant. Usually it's not an issue, but for some reason, right now it's bugging me. I have to see when I get to pro tomorrow.

The lip colors I want are Flaunting It, Peacocky, Super, Exxxhibitionist. I am set on those colors. The only doubt in my mind now is one or two shadows.
 

shontay07108

Well-known member
Yeah, I was doing a side eye at you when you mentioned you loved temper tantra. I was thinking that is not going to work not straight out the box for you but what do I know, I am still getting Peacocky.
Lmfao! I love side eye even when it's directed at me. Why didn't you try talking some sense into me? It's always welcome. Temptalia recommended it for dark skin. I don't consider myself especially dark, but by her definition, I think I fall into that category. I think some people are too typical with what they suggest for a particular skin tone. Temper Tantra might be decent but it's not the kind of color I like.

Oh and we can be blue lipped sisters.
 

Mygreatlove

Well-known member
So I think I have my e/s list narrowed down to:

Prance (This will be perfect with Shale!)
Dalliance (Does this really have a greenish tint? If so, this may be a pass for me.)
Unflappable (LOVE this!! Fantastic looking taupe!)
Centre Stage (Maybe)

I'm having a really hard time passing on/forgetting about Ego. It looks like a great shade of green for people who can't usually rock some greens (like me, lol)...so that may end up coming home too. I'm such a purple nut that I'm shocked about passing on Noir Plum, but it just isn't calling to me for some reason.

For the lips, I'm starting with only Woo Me. If I like the feel/wear time I'll probably be picking up: Love Peck, Scandalicious, and Strut Your Stuff. I really like Exxxhibitionist, but it's far too close to VG Cyndi for me to pick up (I really LOVE VG Cyndi though, so maybe I'll get it anyway, lol). I also like So Vain, but it reminds me of Strange Potion and any number of other l/g I already have so that's a pass. I'm chickening out of Peacocky (sorry Shontay!!), I just can't do it.

Our e/s are the same! Ha... And I'm getting Prance for the same reason!
girlhaha.gif
 

Camnagem

Well-known member
Exxxhibitionist maybe similar to Viva Cyndi but that's fine by me because I was going to buy another Cyndi anyway so that I wouldn't run out. That is my kind of color and I reach for it often. Besides Exxx seems a bit bolder and more pigmented.
This is totally how I feel! I love Cyndi, and a more pigmented version sounds like perfection to me.

I'm trying to be sensible and pass on Exxxhibitionist, and it's totally not working.
lol.gif
 

sss215

Well-known member
Lmfao! I love side eye even when it's directed at me. Why didn't you try talking some sense into me? It's always welcome. Temptalia recommended it for dark skin. I don't consider myself especially dark, but by her definition, I think I fall into that category. I think some people are too typical with what they suggest for a particular skin tone. Temper Tantra might be decent but it's not the kind of color I like.
Oh and we can be blue lipped sisters.
I asked her a while ago if she could swatch a collection (maybe VV) on darker skin and she said she didn't have anyone to swatch it on... so after that, i always wondered about her recommendtions. they are mostly "textbook" when it comes down to it. we can work anything.
 

sss215

Well-known member
Wow, Karla's Swatches are Amazing! Many Thanks! Dandizette is gorgeous! Actually I just loved seeing Dandizette, Spectacle, Center Stage & Unflappable all in a row - bingo - getting all of those Woo Me, Flaunting it, & Scandelicious! and then I'm gonna run ;)

My MA said that Dandizette is similar to Contrast - although to me it looks way more wow than Contrast
She loved Prance a lot! in person. She was really hyper about how much she loved them.
yes! i see that comparison now. contrast is one of my favorites and mostly used!!!! dandizette may be something i look into getting in a few weeks. not rushing out for that at my first attempt.
 

elegant-one

Well-known member
yes! i see that comparison now. contrast is one of my favorites and mostly used!!!! dandizette may be something i look into getting in a few weeks. not rushing out for that at my first attempt.
mine too! it looks like a fab color with some intensity. I'm betting its gorgeous on.
 

shontay07108

Well-known member
See, I'm skipping Dandizette because I have and love Contrast. Contrast looks blah in the pan and even when swatched, but when you put that baby on, it's fire!

Face2Mac, I think it's pretty sad that Temptalia doesn't have at least one person close to our complexion she can swatch colors on. I guess that's why her knowledge of what we can or cannot wear seems so limited.

And Camnagem, I totally tried to talk myself out of Exxx because people kept saying how close it is to Cyndi, but this lippy cannot be denied by me. I would've cried if I passed this because of peer pressure. I know I need this color!
 

ansimi

Well-known member
Karla's swatches help me so much! She's probably about the colour I would be if I lived somewhere with as much sun as wherever she lives and it's great she has sun because it helps her photos:)

I think I'll get Prance and Unflappable since I wear those sorts of colours regularly. Some of the bolder colours are gorgeous but I have a great collection of loose pigments in every colour imaginable and I don't wear those shades often enough to warrant a giant, expensive single.

None of the lip colours are screaming for me but I'm interested in the formula. I hope my store will have sanitary testers set aside so I can try one on my lips. I wonder if these can be blotted down a bit?
 

kelly815

Well-known member
Ive been waiting for MAC to make retrospec usable!!! i was hoping it would come in pigment form but ill deffinitly take a buttery shaddow....I dont see the green tho, but karla said the same thing.
One of my MA said that Dalliance is like Retrospec with a green tinge but a smooth smooth texture.
 

TeresitaMC

Well-known member
Thanks to Temptalia's colourful Peacocky look, I now want Noir Plum (again!) and Odalisque. That look is so pretty! But Noir Plum just takes my breath away, lol.

So if I add these 2, that will be 4 e/s and 2 lipcolours! I was going to use a gift certificate to pay for this haul but if I get 6 items I will have to pay for two. Maybe I will remove So Vain :/

My new, current list:

Center Stage
Dalliance
Noir Plum *new*
Odalisque *new* (maybe?)
Woo Me
So Vain ?
 

Face2Mac

Well-known member
Lmfao! I love side eye even when it's directed at me. Why didn't you try talking some sense into me? It's always welcome. Temptalia recommended it for dark skin. I don't consider myself especially dark, but by her definition, I think I fall into that category. I think some people are too typical with what they suggest for a particular skin tone. Temper Tantra might be decent but it's not the kind of color I like.

Oh and we can be blue lipped sisters.
I can't figure the lipgloss out. Is it a muted coral or a rose color it just doesn't speak to me. But I agree on Super being pretty, Exx and Strut your stuff are pretty too.
 

January

Well-known member
I'm in love with Dalliance... Prance... and Centre Stage

Tweet Me is pretty, but I think I'll just go for Melon Pigment

Sexpectations has the best name - but it looks close enough to Cranberry eyeshadow
 

shontay07108

Well-known member
I can't figure the lipgloss out. Is it a muted coral or a rose color it just doesn't speak to me. But I agree on Super being pretty, Exx and Strut your stuff are pretty too.
At first it looked so light and pretty to me. My lips are kinda dark so I thought it would go on nude for me, but Karla's swatch (which usually seems most accurate) shows it as some kind of chocolatey-rose color. I had a gloss like that before and it made me look like I dipped my mouth into a bowl of fudge. Not cute.
 
Top