MAC Extra Dimension discussion

lmcmullen

Well-known member
Superb and Sweet Heat are the same color but different textures (I have both). I tried Superb as an eyeshadow and found it a bit sheer and grainy for that purpose. Sweet Heat is smoother and much more opaque.

If I could only get one I'd probably get Sweet Heat, as you could use that as a highlighter (applied with a light hand) and it's more successful as an eyeshadow, in my opinion.
 

MACa6325xi

Well-known member
Superb and Sweet Heat are the same color but different textures (I have both). I tried Superb as an eyeshadow and found it a bit sheer and grainy for that purpose. Sweet Heat is smoother and much more opaque.

If I could only get one I'd probably get Sweet Heat, as you could use that as a highlighter (applied with a light hand) and it's more successful as an eyeshadow, in my opinion.
Thanks for this. I agree with you about the different textures. I have been wearing Sweet Heat as a lid color and highlight. I decided to order Superb because the texture is softer for the face.
 

duckrodeo

Well-known member
Went to my MAC counter today and Dark Dare jumped into my bag. Oh no!
angelic.gif
Team 9 yeahhhh.

While I haven't tried or purchased Sweet Heat, I'm satisfied with the color payoff Superb gives me on the eyes. It's satisfactory for me to use for neutral "bare" eyes to pair with bold lips.
 

MACerette

Well-known member
I have only bought Superb, Whisper of Gilt and Modern Pewter. I am still lemming Lunar and Dark Dare although I am trying to tell myself not to buy them. I have tried Superb several times now and wondering if I need a backup...
 

SweetSarah

Well-known member
I definitely need a backup of Superb. And I want Dark Dare (damn you, liba :)) and YV.

Today is my first day back at work so hopefully it's busy and I make a lot of $$
 

VampOwl

Well-known member
I'm now Team 8 for the eyeshadows! I'm still debating if I want to make it Team 10 (or 9). The only two I am missing are Havana and Sweet Heat. How is everyone liking Havana? It seems to lack that sheen that all of the others have yet it still is appealing. And as for Sweet Heat, I already have Superb but reading that Sweet Heat is more opaque is tempting.
 

bis

Well-known member
If I could get just one skin finish, which one should I get? I'd like a light and cool one. Thanks!
 

Babylard

Well-known member
depends on your understones. on my NC20, whisper of guilt and superb run pretty warm on me. whisper of guilt is lighter, but it is a yellow gold. superb is peachy and a bit darker. I would have liked to see a lightscapade version in the extra dimensions formula ;D
If I could get just one skin finish, which one should I get? I'd like a light and cool one. Thanks!
 

Piarpreet

Well-known member
I had a MACasm thinking about it....
depends on your understones. on my NC20, whisper of guilt and superb run pretty warm on me. whisper of guilt is lighter, but it is a yellow gold. superb is peachy and a bit darker. I would have liked to see a lightscapade version in the extra dimensions formula ;D
 

mac_aiken

Well-known member
Between you and Liba, I am now lemming this. I have never been able to do a smokey eye (I think I have yet to learn the right technique) but I am intrigued by this one. How can I use it without looking like someone punched me in the eye? I am pretty pale (NW15/N2).
I definitely need a backup of Superb. And I want Dark Dare (damn you, liba :)) and YV.

Today is my first day back at work so hopefully it's busy and I make a lot of $$
 

Ashleybubbles83

Well-known member
Looks like I'm going to be Team 5! Haha I have rich core, grand galaxy and young Venus. Picked up Lunar yesterday as I was trying to "subtly pass by the MAC counter." And I'll get Dark Dare on Friday!
 

lyseD

Well-known member
I have rich core, grand galaxy and young Venus. Picked up Lunar yesterday as I was trying to "subtly pass by the MAC counter." And I'll get Dark Dare on Friday!

Love Lunar! I also have Rich Core and Sweet Heat. I just added Modern Pewter to my birthday list (May baby here) and told my husband to hurry up on the LE items.
amuse.gif
 

duckrodeo

Well-known member
Between you and Liba, I am now lemming this. I have never been able to do a smokey eye (I think I have yet to learn the right technique) but I am intrigued by this one. How can I use it without looking like someone punched me in the eye? I am pretty pale (NW15/N2).
I'm really pale, too, so sometimes it's hard for me to do a smokey eye without it just looking like one solid color on my eyelids. I find using a really densely-packed brush helps to get a dark color and pack it on the lid without it going into bruise territory and also helps create a gradient effect to still add dimension to the lid. I usually like to apply a dark color on the outer V area. If I put a super dark color in my crease then it doesn't settle well. So I usually use a matte gray or depending on the color scheme of shadows, a dark matte brown works for the crase. The brush I use is made for blending so it helps pack the color on and spread it out, rather than it being too concentrated. I use this one: http://www.urbandecay.com/24-7-shadow-pencil-blending-brush/285,default,pd.html?start=14&cgid=11 it does a pretty good job of packing color on, and it's a soft synthetic brush but stiff enough to do its job. HTH!

Ohhh also: xsparkage is one of my favorite bloggers with tutorials. She does an awesome job explaining her eyeshadow application and is amaazing at smokey eyes. She's also pretty pale, too! So she's a great reference :)
 

Mac-Guy

Well-known member
I combined Superb with Full of Joy =
heart2.gif


I used S as a base for FoJ and added S as a highlight. It's absolutely lovely as it brings out the sheen of FoJ while intensifying the lavender.
love.gif
 
Top