MAC by Request (April 1,2014)

Lipstickdiva420

Well-known member
lol.gif

im sure she's too busy now to do vids like she used to esp between traveling for classes n celebs!! its amazing to see her hard work finally pay off. very inspirational.


i only voted once...ok maybe twice! i honestly dnt give a dmn which lipstick wins n maybe its just the azzhole-ness in ME but im not apologizing for how i feel regardless of who cries about hurt feelings or not. THERE ARE NO LOSERS IN MAKEUP!!! Am i in kindergarden class?
lmao.gif
but i do like how yall can be the bigger person n apologize ("sorry not sorry" tag). is anybody winning a prize or free lipstick for all this extra-ness? oh wait...just FREE SHIPPING right mmmm ok!! (i know dmn well i aint the only one who feels this way)!!! i am lookin fwd to butterscotch
drama.gif
Yes I'm sure of that too and I just started watching her a couple of months ago. I see she's done Brandy and Nicki Minaj's make up so proud of her and very inspiring. Lol I don't care too much of which one wins either and I want to see what's the big deal about butterscotch.
 

vaisforluvrs

Well-known member
I leave this thread for a day, and all hell breaks loose! Lol My top 3 have always been Rozz, Hoop and Pink Poodle (yep, there are people who want this color
tong.gif
) I voted for Rozz the most, but threw in votes to the other two depending on the count that day. Honestly, I never understood the love for Glam especially since Temptalia said it was the most dupe-able (so many classic reds out there). I never figured out how to vote more than once a day so I just left it to fate. I do believe that the other colors will probably make it back, just in disguise, maybe a different name. MAC probably just uses this to test their customers to see what kind of colors they will buy in the future, lol.
 

Yazmin

Well-known member
I'm so sad about Fiction!! I wont be getting any of the shadows. And I hope at least Hoop makes it. And I finally figured out my Fiction dupe is Flourishing. Look different in pan but very similar on wrist swatches. I'd show you if I wasn't technology challenged-- I have no clue how to upload pix.
I have Flourishing, so I can skip Fiction. And since NARS Bali is darker than but similar to Ashbury, that's a skip for me also. Those two would have been the only items I would have wanted from the collection. Not interested in the lipsticks.
 

singer82

Well-known member
Know what? After seeing the colors on an actual computer and not just my phone, I think I actually like Pink Poodle! I love the Glaze formula, I love grab and go kind of formulas. I dont just like my brights bold, toned down brights I love as well.

So...wonder what the other two colors are. We know PP is one.
 

martiangurll

Well-known member
I have Flourishing, so I can skip Fiction. And since NARS Bali is darker than but similar to Ashbury, that's a skip for me also. Those two would have been the only items I would have wanted from the collection. Not interested in the lipsticks.
How do the finishes compare?
 

Naughtyp

Well-known member
I was looking at Ts swatches and Pink Poodle, Glam and Hoop are all marked P and the other three Are marked LE.... don't know if that means anything but just something that made me go, hmmmm?
 

Richelle83

Well-known member
I was looking at Ts swatches and Pink Poodle, Glam and Hoop are all marked P and the other three Are marked LE.... don't know if that means anything but just something that made me go, hmmmm?
I noticed too but was thinking that maybe MAC made a typo. Of course it wouldn't be a bad idea if they released all 6(doubt they'll do it lol)
 

martiangurll

Well-known member
I noticed too but was thinking that maybe MAC made a typo. Of course it wouldn't be a bad idea if they released all 6(doubt they'll do it lol)
I agree with the theory advanced here that the whole voting thing was a marketing technique to find out what colors will be popular in future collections and I don't think they will be re-released per se, but maybe in a slightly different color or finish?
shrugs.gif
Just my $0.02
 

SavannahLovely

Well-known member
I have my own theory. Maybe they are going to make the top three permanent, and the losing three will be brought back as limited edition for By Request.
 

BrinaBoo10

Well-known member
Quote:Originally Posted by SavannahLovely

I have my own theory. Maybe they are going to make the top three permanent, and the losing three will be brought back as limited edition for By Request.


I would love that as well!
 
Top