I only used eye pencils for years. I had one or two fluidlines from waaay back in bright colors and didn't use them much. Then, the Superslick liners came out around the time I got back into makeup full force and I liked the applicator. Once I finally got handy with an angled liner brush is when I really embraced fluidlines. I still use pencils for that smudgy punk look, which I'll never let go of, but there is no denying a fabulous cat eye - that's a look that isn't going to go out of style again for a long time.
I honestly prefer all the LE fluidlines to the perm ones (I'm not a huge fan of Blacktrack - I know, heresy, but I'd rather use Wholesome every single time). The ones in this collection are going to be amazing. You'd get the maximum fluidline experience getting Dark Ivy, that's for sure. It looks amazing and top shelf!!! It's going to be BU city for me.
I'm not always a paint pot person. Some of them are a little too heavy on my skin and accentuate all my lid texture, but when they're good, they're great. This last batch of new editions like Camel Coat and Stormy Pink are so good - smooth and not heavy. I use Stormy Pink for cheek contouring too! Dangerous Cuvee has always been my favorite of the sparkly ones. 'Was glad they made it perm.
If you want to read up, I talked about them a ton when they first came out. They have a very comfortable formula that lasts and lasts. They also have a a pH adjusting formula, though, so you won't always wind up with the color you first applied. That got annoying for me, because I couldn't really plan my look. They're better for just wearing on their own on low makeup days, so they won't clash as the day goes on. Sort of surprised they're back, but I bet after this, that'll be the end of them.