MAC Charlotte Olympia (March 17, 2016)

Myth

Well-known member
Just a 249, loving the acrylic
Love the spider mascara but I just can't with brown mascara lol
 

Corally

Well-known member
T's got swatches of Retro Rouge here

http://www.temptalia.com/product/mac-charlotte-olympia-lipstick/retro-rouge?i=224079


View attachment 52802

Im a little let down bc I thought it would've been darker, like burgandy. I might just pick it up tho because I love the tacky packaging not gonna lie lol

I expected it to be darker as well, not burgundy but quite a bit darker. I still like it but not in love and I'm not sure if I'm gonna get it. And really I wish the lippies came in the bullet packaging, I hate this cheap plastic square packaging. And it'll probably won't even fit in my lipstick holders. So that also holds me back.
 

leonah

Well-known member
I expected it to be darker as well, not burgundy but quite a bit darker. I still like it but not in love and I'm not sure if I'm gonna get it. And really I wish the lippies came in the bullet packaging, I hate this cheap plastic square packaging. And it'll probably won't even fit in my lipstick holders. So that also holds me back.

I know! but if I'm going to get anyone of these lipsticks I probably will en up with the darker one since the other two look even more dupable (and what I already have in my collection) so..
 

lilinah

Well-known member
That Crimson Lip Mix looks good and dark and cooler (not warmer). It is tempting me.

And BROWN mascara! I was going to skip this collection, but brown mascara is so much better than black!

Nothing else is calling to me, but i do like the packaging. Spiders are good. Now i'm going to have to check this out when it hits the stores.
 

NaomiH

Well-known member
This packaging is so hideous, but I'm still down for all three lipsticks. Can't be passing up them reds!
 

LavenderPearl

Well-known member
So is now going to be available everywhere instead of select markets? All these reds are blurring together, I'm thinking I can skip but Starlett Scarlet might warrant an in-person swatching... and to see this packaging up close. Fingers crossed the makeup bag ends up at the CCO, but overall still holding out for other collex I think x__x
 

Shars

Well-known member
So is now going to be available everywhere instead of select markets? All these reds are blurring together, I'm thinking I can skip but Starlett Scarlet might warrant an in-person swatching... and to see this packaging up close. Fingers crossed the makeup bag ends up at the CCO, but overall still holding out for other collex I think x__x

I'm hoping the bag and the mirror end up at the CCO as well. They're cute, but not full retail price cute lol.
 

Corally

Well-known member
Aaah crap starting to love all three now. Like whyyy. I HATE that packaging. Tempted to buy them all just so they'll have ugly buddies lol. But I'll probably end up with Retro Rouge and Starlett Scarlet.
 
Top