Least Fav. E/S & Pigment

[Shannyn]

Out of all of the eyeshadows and pigments of mac which would you say was your least favorite from each:

For me.....

Eyeshadow:
Jasmine- When I bought it I thought it was going to be such a pretty color on me but when I applied it to my eyes it looked horrible on me.

Pigment:
Rose- When I tested it in the store it looked pretty in my hand but it made my eyes look very weird. I didn't really like how it came out on me.

 

[selina]

E/S - Au Contraire -- I looked like I got punched in the eye

Pigment - Fairylite, what was the point of this? It didn't show up on my skin. And I'd have to agree with Rose -- ICK, I wanted to like this sooo much but it I don't know, it's a weird color to describe.

 

[Shawna]

e/s: plum from madame b - so pretty to look at, but the colour does not show up on me no matter what I do. It ends up looking like mud.

pigment: rose definitely. I so wanted this, but it just flakes off my eyes and makes me look like I've been crying.

 

[Lo-Fi_Thriller]

Eyeshadows: i cant stand Vellum, Soft Brown, any nutral Matte Brown really, except concrete which i use on my brows.

Pigment: i agree about Fairylite, it sucks ass, it dosent show up on me and im pretty pale, its like a dying wilted pink with some kind of sparkles. i had a sample of the old Fairylite and i liked it and i bought the new one and it sucks ass.

 

[beautifulxdisaster]

I didn't like peridot eyeshadow at all!!!

 

[roxybc]

Eye Shadow: Jewel Blue - ick! I hate it with a passion, I've tried and tried to get it to work, and it just doesn't show up AT ALL! The formula is horrible, and goes on very uneven on me.

Pigment: Out of the few I have, it's got to be Blue Brown. I'm so fair skinned and blonde that it looks like I have bruised eyes when I wear it. all you notice is the reddish brown color. I seriously look like a crack whore when I wear this!

 

[user2]

Eyeshadow:
Chrome Yellow - I cant work any matte for me...it looks boring and sheer and I'm not sad about it getting discontinued

Pigment:
Frost...I look like I rushed into a blizzard...and its so not that kind of pigment I wanted it to be!!

 

[Sanne]

e/s: tilt, creme de violet, jewel blue
pigments: frost, cornflower.

 

[Cruella]

I hate Mulch e/s. It is always recommended to me because I have greenish eyes but the red in it makes my eyes look so tired and ill.

My least favorite pigment is Kitschmas. It is just too light and glittery.

 

[Sushi_Flower]

Ohno, i looked at Pigments for the 1st time today and only liked Rose and want to buy it. Why is it so bad? On my hand it looked pinky/gold?

 

[thegirlgotsoul]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lo-Fi_Thriller Eyeshadows: i cant stand Vellum...

Aw. I just bought Vellum today and I tried it out paired over Felt Blue and I LOOOVE it.

 

[Jillith]

most hated shadows: I totally agree about jasmine and jewel blue. So ugly on me.

most hated pigment: dark soul. talcy and gritty. not eye safe. what the hell am i supposed to do with it?

 

[litlaur]

Shadow: Any lustre really. Swimming was the most disappointing.

Pigment: Teal because it's not eyesafe, yet it looks great.

 

[Jessica]

**hides and whispers**I love all of my shadows and pigments

 

[Shawna]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sushi_Flower Ohno, i looked at Pigments for the 1st time today and only liked Rose and want to buy it. Why is it so bad? On my hand it looked pinky/gold?

Its texture is similar to lustre e/s and it just doesn't want to stay on my skin. It is beautiful on the back of my hand, but on my eyes, yuck. I look like I have been crying, and it flakes off. I have tried it over paints, and shadesticks, and urban decay primer potion, but no luck. That being said, I absolutely love it as a sparkley blush, and maybe it would work on you. Try asking for a sample of it, or get an MA to apply some on you. Then you can see how it lasts. HTH.

 

[Jessica]

Not sure if you ladies have tried applying Rose wet on top of paint (i use bare canvas) but it says on well for me. I dunno, maybe I'm weird

 

[MacLover]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jessica **hides and whispers**I love all of my shadows and pigments

So do I!

I always make them try the eyeshadow on me before I buy it. I don't want to go through the hassel of having to bring it back.

 

[MACForME]

Hmmpff..
I loved GLEAM e/s when i bought it, but to use it at home? UGH! Some of those lustre shadows end up ON MY FACE, and streak on the eye. I am trying to use a CCB under it and its then TOO much.

pigment- silver.. wayyy tooo much

 

[glamella]

Pink Bronze pigment is neither pink nor bronze. I was really disappointed becaus ewhen it's on, it looks nothing like what it does in the jar.

Satin Taupe makes me look like I have a bruised eye.

 

[askewchick]

Eyeshadows: Retrospeck, Shale, D'Bohemia, Sprout, Tilt, Beaded

Pigments: Rose, Blue Brown, All-Girl