Palettes review continued
Inside, you will find the six eyeshadows. First we have Scant, a frosted yellow-cream. It has a gentle pinky opalescence, so it reminds me of a less dramatic Pink Opal (pigment). Very cool. Gorgeous is a pale white-silver frost. It is Rondelle(Danse 06, Smoke Signals 07, Metallic palette 07)'s twin. They both apply bright and clean, but I do think that Gorgeous is slightly more grey, but they are close enough. Next we have Satin Taupe, which is permanent and one of my FAVORITE colors ever. It's a beautiful cool brown-taupe with silver frostyness. It applies very smooth, and it's so pretty,one of MAC's most popular shades. Some people dislike it, but I for one loooove it. Perfect for a smokey eye, either all over the lid or as a crease and liner. Ambiance is a velvet and Grey Fume (Smokey palette 06, Smoke Signals 07)'s doppelganger. A slightly metallic mid-tone dirty grey with silver sparkles. It is hard to build and hard to blend, much like it's twin, Grey Fume. I'm not impressed by this color. It's alright, but Silver Ring is a much better choice for a dirty grey/silver. Dark Devotion is a satin and Oh-So-Pretty! It applies surprisingly even and opaque for a matte. However, it is Showstopper (Dianna Ross 04?, Smoke Signals 07, Warm palette 07) with a new name, no kidding. It's a deep black-brown. Sooo beautiful on anyone! Can be used as a liner, crease color, even lid color for alot of drama. Can go with anything. But if you have Showstopper you already have it. Lastly we have Carbon, which is MAC's classic black matte eyeshadow. A staple in my collection, and I for one have SOOO many already. It is repromoted very often, just like Satin Taupe, and here's another time MAC is shoving it down our throats. I swear, if someone doesn't have Carbon by now they don't want it MAC! However, it does go lovely with the rest of the palette.
A note about the Smoky palette this year is that it is like a combination of the two smoky palettes included in Smoke Signals 07, the problem being they didn't include the more unique colors of the two quads (Smoking from Smoking eyes, and Waft from Gentle Fume eyes). The point is, if you already own those two palettes, you don't need this new one at all, and chances are if you are into this type of look and an avid MAC collector, you already have these shades in one form or another. Just wanted to point that out!
QUOTE]
You are dead-on about Ambiance and Gentle Fume...they are the exact same color. I have both and swatched side-by-side there is no difference. I know Mac is in the business to make $$ but it deceitful to change the name of an already released color and promote it as 'new' and 'exclusive'.